Tom Hardy’s Peaky Blinders return has been confirmed by the creator

Why Alfie still matters

Tom Hardy’s return to the Peaky Blinders world became news after the new movie arrived without Alfie Solomons. Fans had spent days wondering whether the sharp-tongued Camden boss would step back into Tommy Shelby’s orbit again.

That curiosity made sense because Alfie stayed one of the show’s most memorable figures, even though he appeared in only 13 episodes. His scenes with Tommy carried such force that his absence from the movie stood out to longtime viewers.

A role fans never forgot

Many viewers see Alfie Solomons as Tom Hardy’s strongest television performance, even alongside his major movie work over the last decade. Before and after Peaky Blinders, Hardy built a huge profile through Inception, Mad Max: Fury Road, and Venom movies.

That larger career made Alfie’s impact more striking because the character never needed constant screen time to leave a mark. He shifted between ally and enemy, giving Tommy some of the show’s sharpest, most unpredictable exchanges.

The beach shooting changed things

Alfie and Tommy seemed to finish their business in season four when Tommy shot Alfie in the face on Margate beach. For a while, that moment looked like a final goodbye for one of the series’ most unusual and tense relationships.

The surprise came later, when Alfie returned alive with a brutal scar on his cheek. That comeback fueled later fan theories because, after the shooting, Tommy and Alfie were only ever seen alone together.

Why the movie raised questions

The sequel film, The Immortal Man, brought Tommy Shelby back and moved his story into the Second World War. With Cillian Murphy returning and several familiar faces involved, many fans hoped Alfie would also appear somewhere in the story.

Instead, he was missing, and that disappointment became one of the biggest talking points around the film. The reaction was understandable because Hardy had said in 2024 that he hoped to return as Alfie Solomons someday.

Steven Knight had a plan

The creator said there was an idea for Alfie to appear in the movie before that version was dropped. He explained that ever since the Margate shooting, Tommy and Alfie had only been shown together alone, with nobody else there.

That detail led to a darker possibility for the film’s story. Knight considered having Alfie appear again, only for viewers to realize that he had actually been dead the whole time since Tommy shot him.

The twist almost became real

The abandoned idea would have turned Alfie into something even stranger than fans expected. Instead of a straightforward comeback, his appearance would have confirmed that Tommy had been speaking to a dead man for years.

That twist fits a theory some fans already discussed during the show’s later seasons. Tommy had a pattern of confronting ghosts from his past, so making Alfie another apparition almost became part of the official story itself for many viewers.

Little-known fact: The story came from a family tale Steven Knight heard from his father about delivering a message to relatives linked to the real Birmingham gang that inspired the Shelbys.

Why Knight walked away from it

Even though Knight considered using that version, he decided not to include it in the finished film. That choice likely avoided deepening a divide among viewers, since the movie was already drawing mixed reactions over its ending.

Revealing that Alfie had been dead all along would have changed how fans viewed his appearances in seasons five and six. For a beloved character, that rewrite could have landed as too big a shock for many viewers.

The story chose the cast

Knight made clear that the story determined who appeared in The Immortal Man. His point was simple: the cast followed the shape of the plot, and this movie was built around where Tommy’s journey needed to go.

He also said a film does not have the same room as a long series. Once the focus locked onto Tommy and Duke as the main engines, there was less room to bring back major figures like Alfie.

Tommy’s world had moved on

The film picks up Tommy’s story in 1940, six years after the main series ended. He is drawn into events around Operation Bernhard, the real Nazi plot to flood Britain with counterfeit currency and damage the economy.

At the same time, the story centers on Tommy’s guilt, isolation, and his effort to save his son, Duke. With so much weight on war, family, and personal reckoning, Alfie’s return no longer fit the final story shape.

Fun fact: Jason Statham was once the first choice to play Tommy Shelby, until Cillian Murphy fought for the part and won it.

Fans were not imagining it

The idea of Alfie being unreal did not come out of nowhere. Knight pointed out that after the beach shooting, Tommy and Alfie were only ever shown together, which gave that possibility real weight.

That is why his comments landed so strongly with longtime fans. A theory that had floated around for years suddenly turned out to be close enough to the creator’s thinking that it almost became canon in the movie itself.

Hardy always kept Alfie alive

There is another reason Alfie’s story feels unusually open-ended. Knight said Hardy pushed back when Alfie was killed in season four, sending messages insisting that Alfie was not dead and helping bring him back.

That behind-the-scenes detail matches the character’s strange survival on screen. Alfie went from seeming finished on the beach to reappearing later, which strengthened his legend and kept fans believing another return could still happen.

The movie was still a hit

Even with debate around its ending and disappointment over missing characters, The Immortal Man still had no trouble climbing the streaming charts. That shows how strong the Peaky Blinders name remains, even after the original series ended.

The farewell to Tommy was always meant to carry emotional weight, and the film was built as that final chapter. For many fans, though, Alfie’s absence remained one of the loudest what-ifs surrounding the whole release.

Want another Tom Hardy pick after this? Check out his 85-minute A24 thriller, which has become a smart streaming choice for viewers who want something tense without a huge time commitment.

This may not be the end

Knight has already confirmed that a follow-up series is being written to continue the Shelby legacy in the 1950s. He has also said that some characters from The Immortal Man will appear there, though he is keeping the specifics quiet.

That does not confirm anything about Alfie Solomons, but it keeps the larger world moving forward. After hearing how close Hardy came to returning, fans now have one more reason to keep watching what happens next.

Still wondering what really happened to Arthur Shelby? Check out how Steven Knight opens up about the mystery around his fate in Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man.

Do you think Alfie could still turn up later, or should the next chapter focus on a new generation? Share your take in the comments.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

Read More From This Brand:

• Cillian Murphy shares his honest thoughts on his Peaky Blinders character’s iconic haircut
• Cillian Murphy issued a spoiler warning as the ‘Peaky Blinders’ film arrived on Netflix
• Tim Roth says he made an important change to his Peaky Blinders villain