The lip-sync moments they hoped you’d miss

Mariah Carey’s New Year’s nightmare

Mariah’s 2016 New Year’s Eve set didn’t exactly ring in the year with sparkle, unless you count the sound of jaws hitting the floor. As her vocals played on without her, she just strolled around the stage like she was waiting for room service.

When things went south, instead of salvaging the moment, the queen of high notes tapped out. Fans were left asking: If even Mariah can’t fake it right, should we expect anyone to sing live anymore?

Ashlee Simpson’s SNL disaster

Ashlee’s 2004 SNL disaster hit before she could even open her mouth, literally. With vocals rolling and no mic to her lips, she panic-jigged across the stage in a move that screamed, “Get me outta here!”

She later blamed it on acid reflux, but the damage was already done; America wasn’t buying it. One awkward shuffle and a mic-less mystery track later, and her credibility took a nosedive no choreo could save.

Milli Vanilli’s Grammy disgrace

Things unraveled fast for Milli Vanilli when their track started skipping live on Club MTV, and they just kept dancing like nothing happened. Spoiler: that’s not what real vocals do.

Turns out the duo hadn’t sung anything on their hit album, yet still snagged a Grammy, until it was ripped right back. From chart-toppers to lawsuits, they lip-synced their way into music history… for all the wrong reasons.

Beyoncé’s inaugural confession

In 2013, Beyoncé stunned fans, not with a high note, but by fessing up to lip-syncing the national anthem at Obama’s inauguration. Blaming time crunches and high stakes, she played it safe for the world’s biggest stage.

But leave it to Queen Bey to flip the script; she belted it live at a press conference like it was no big deal. Lesson learned: When you’re that talented, a little honesty and a lot of vocal flexing can silence the critics.

Whitney Houston’s Super Bowl “secret”

In 1991, Whitney delivered a jaw-dropping national anthem at the Super Bowl, but surprise, it was lip-synced. Her producer later revealed it was a pre-recorded track made to avoid technical mishaps.

Yet no one really cared because it was that flawless. The anthem even hit the Billboard charts, proving sometimes a fake live moment can still be truly iconic.

Britney Spears’ 2007 VMA blunder

Britney’s much-hyped VMA comeback in 2007 fizzled fast when she awkwardly mouthed through Gimme More like she’d rather be anywhere else. One giggle mid-track, and fans knew, this wasn’t live, and it wasn’t good.

Critics pounced, calling it lazy and lifeless, but context mattered, she was going through a lot. Sadly, the performance became more about pity than pop, marking a low note in her storied career.

Ellie Goulding’s AFL fumble

Ellie took the stage at the 2015 AFL pre-game show, but her vocals kicked in way before she did. For a good 20 seconds, the track played while she just stood there, frozen like someone hit pause.

When she finally jumped in, things didn’t exactly smooth out, missed cues and awkward timing made it rough to watch. She pointed fingers at the sound techs, but hey, the tape doesn’t lie… and neither does a silent mouth.

50 Cent’s BET Awards walk-off

You don’t expect lip-sync drama from a rapper, but 50 Cent proved otherwise at the 2007 BET Awards. As his track kicked in, his mic wasn’t even close to his mouth, and yet, the vocals kept flowing.

Instead of catching up, he just strolled around like it was a soundcheck, casually chatting mid-song. When he finally returned to the mic, that backing track was still going strong… and so were the questions.

Shakira’s World Cup wobble

Shakira brought the heat to the 2010 World Cup, but while her hips were in sync, her lips… not so much. She-Wolf blared on, but her mouth wasn’t always cooperating, and neither was the camera.

From awkward timing to frequent back turns, it all screamed pre-recorded. We get it, dancing takes breath—but come on, Shakira, we were watching the whole show.

Katy Perry’s NRJ oopsie

Katy Perry’s known for bringing it live, but her 2013 NRJ Awards gig gave us two versions of Roar. First take? Her mic was down, but her voice was up, definitely a lip-sync moment caught red-handed.

Then the host stopped the show and asked for a redo, cue the real vocals and a very different sound. It was awkward, sure, but Katy bounced back and proved she’s got the pipes when it counts.

Britney’s X Factor fail

Britney wowed with the moves on The X Factor UK, but vocally? Let’s just say her mic was on vacation. Womanizer played loud and clear, but her lips were just along for the ride.

The dead giveaway came post-performance when the host had to lend his mic so she could speak. Fans quickly realized: her mic was probably never on, and the whole thing was one big, sparkly charade.

Selena Gomez’s Jingle Ball slip-up

At the 2013 Jingle Ball in L.A., Selena Gomez hit the stage, but her vocals showed up before her mic did. As Come and Get It played, her lips lagged behind, and a quick head turn couldn’t hide the blunder.

Clearly frustrated, she dropped an expletive at the end, unfiltered and fully live. The moment showed that even pop stars crack under pressure… especially when the track beats them to the chorus.

Cheryl’s soundtrack shuffle

During the 2012 Stand Up To Cancer special, Cheryl danced her heart out, but forgot to bring her vocals along. For nearly 90 seconds, all we heard were breathy grunts over a mysteriously solo backing track.

Unlike Katy Perry, she didn’t get a do-over, just awkward silence and secondhand embarrassment. And when she tried again on The X Factor two years later, well… let’s just say history repeated itself.

Nicki Minaj’s “Starships” fail

In 2012, Nicki Minaj brought Starships to the Today Show, but something felt off, like her mic was just along for the ride. Her vocals sounded exactly like the album, even while she bounced around without missing a beat.

Fans noticed fast, because breathless cardio usually messes with pitch, not here though. It was one of those “is she even singing?” moments that morning shows seem to specialize in.

Hilary Duff’s New Year’s “déjà vu”

Hilary Duff hit the MTV New Year’s Eve stage in 2004 with Come Clean, but something smelled suspiciously like studio magic. Her “live” vocals matched the album version a little too perfectly.

Then came the slip-up: a clear audio skip right before the chorus, and Hilary didn’t flinch. She powered through like nothing happened, but fans watching knew, this performance came pre-packaged.

Curious how other artists have called out the music scene? Check out these country songs that don’t hold back.

Lil Nas X’s VMA debut

At the 2019 VMAs, rising star Lil Nas X performed his follow-up hit Panini with futuristic costumes and choreography. Despite the impressive visual production, viewers quickly pointed out how his mouth movements didn’t align with the vocals coming through speakers.

As a newcomer to performing live on major stages, the Old Town Road singer faced criticism for not singing live at his first VMAs. This incident highlighted the pressure new artists face when transitioning from studio success to live performance expectations.

Love a good live performance? Take a look at the most covered rock songs of all time and see which classics keep coming back.

If you liked this post, don’t forget to hit the like button and drop a comment.

Read More From This Brand:

• These Are the Happiest + Saddest Songs in Country Music
• Grand Ole Opry’s Biggest Hit Songs of the 80s Revealed
• Why These Country Singers Are Overrated

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.