The 17 Biggest TV Flops of All Time, Ranked

When Hype Fails to Deliver

Some TV shows fail to make a lasting impact, despite ambitious budgets and star power. Poor storylines, lackluster reception, and missteps in execution led to their rapid rise and quicker fall into obscurity.

These shows, with massive expectations, failed to connect with audiences. While they featured impressive casts and high production values, they lacked the right elements to captivate viewers, showing that hype alone can’t guarantee success on the small screen.

17th: Vinyl (2016)

Vinyl, an HBO drama about the 1970s music industry, came with legendary names like Martin Scorsese and Mick Jagger attached. HBO poured around $100 million ($122m/£97m today) into the show, expecting a groundbreaking success story.

Despite strong initial buzz, Vinyl earned a 64/100 Metacritic critic score and a user score of 6.8/10. However, ratings never took off, and only 0.76 million tuned in for the finale. HBO canceled the show after one expensive season.

16th: Terra Nova (2011)

Terra Nova was a highly ambitious sci-fi series from Fox, set in a prehistoric world. It had an eye-watering $14 million ($18m/£14m today) pilot cost and around $4 million ($5m/£4m) per episode afterward.

Despite its massive investment, Terra Nova scored a 64/100 on Metacritic with a 7.0/10 user rating. It premiered to decent numbers, but steep production costs and mediocre storytelling led Fox to cancel it after one season.

15th: The Event (2010)

NBC had high hopes for The Event, a political sci-fi thriller. With a complex narrative and high production value, it aimed to become the network’s next big hit.

Despite strong initial interest, The Event dropped sharply in ratings, averaging a Metacritic critic score of 67/100 and a user score of 7.0/10. NBC canceled it after one season, citing declining viewership and high production costs.

14th: The Mist (2017)

Based on Stephen King’s novella, The Mist arrived with high expectations on Spike TV. Its budget reportedly hovered around $23 million ($29m/£23m today) for one season, banking on King’s popularity to drive viewership.

Sadly, it scored a weak 54/100 on Metacritic and 4.5/10 from users. Critics slammed its slow pace and lack of character depth, leading to a ratings collapse. Spike canceled the series after only 10 episodes.

13th: Marco Polo (2014)

Netflix invested heavily in historical drama Marco Polo, spending a massive $200 million ($247m/£196m today) across two seasons. It aimed to rival Game of Thrones but never caught fire with viewers.

With a Metacritic critic score of just 48/100 and user score of 7.3/10, the numbers didn’t justify the spending. Netflix reported huge losses and ultimately pulled the plug after two seasons, calling it a “commercial disappointment.”

12th: FlashForward (2009)

ABC hyped FlashForward as the next Lost. Its high-concept storyline promised an exciting sci-fi mystery across the globe, teasing audiences with puzzle-like storytelling and intense marketing.

Despite a strong start, ratings plunged after initial episodes. It scored 62/100 on Metacritic and 7.5/10 with viewers. Story complications and viewer confusion forced ABC to cancel it after one expensive and disappointing season.

11th: Camelot (2011)

Starz spent approximately $7 million ($9m/£7m today) per episode on Camelot, hoping to craft a gritty, mature retelling of Arthurian legends. With an all-star cast, the network invested heavily in epic sets and high fantasy visuals.

Although the show had a 58/100 Metacritic critic score and a 7.4/10 user rating, it couldn’t sustain viewership. Behind-the-scenes turmoil and scheduling issues ultimately doomed it, leading to cancellation after just one uneven and costly season.

10th: Emily’s Reasons Why Not (2006)

ABC heavily promoted Emily’s Reasons Why Not, hoping Heather Graham’s star power would pull viewers. Though the exact budget isn’t confirmed, reports suggest a major investment in production and marketing, pushing millions into the short-lived project.

Critics were brutal, awarding the pilot a 48/100 Metacritic critic score and a 4.5/10 user rating. The immediate backlash forced ABC to yank the show off the air after just one poorly received episode.

9th: No Ordinary Family (2010)

ABC hoped No Ordinary Family would combine superhero action with family warmth to create a hit. Though exact budgets aren’t confirmed, the effects-heavy series starring Michael Chiklis and Julie Benz clearly demanded a sizeable investment.

Despite early promise, inconsistent storytelling and weaker later episodes led ABC to cancel it after a single season.

8th: Marvel’s Inhumans (2017)

Marvel’s Inhumans premiered with much hype, costing $8 million ($10m/£8m today). ABC hoped it would dominate fall TV, leveraging Marvel’s growing brand to capture sci-fi audiences hungry for superhero content.

Instead, critics slammed it (27/100 Metacritic score, 5.2/10 user rating). Poor effects, awkward writing, and dull characters made Inhumans Marvel’s first major TV failure, leading ABC to cancel the show after one dismal season.

7th: The Secret Circle (2011)

CW’s The Secret Circle was a supernatural teen drama, it did not have a publicly released budget. With witches, romance, and mystery, it targeted Vampire Diaries fans craving another juicy, magic-filled ensemble story.

Although it scored 57/100 on Metacritic and 7.3/10 among users, expensive production costs versus average ratings spelled doom. CW canceled it after one season, sparking massive fan petitions for revival that never materialized.

6th: Almost Human (2013)

Fox spent nearly $3-4 million ($4.5m/£3.5m today) per episode on Almost Human, set in a futuristic world where humans partnered with androids. The show’s major selling points were sleek designs, action-packed scenes, and a likable cast.

Despite a 69/100 Metacritic critic score and 8.0/10 user rating, inconsistent airing schedules hurt viewership. Fox canceled it after one expensive season, frustrating fans who appreciated its smart, stylish blend of sci-fi and character-driven drama.

5th: Blood & Treasure (2019)

CBS banked on Blood & Treasure, it did not have a publicly released budget. A globe-trotting treasure-hunt series with action, history, and romance, it tried to blend Indiana Jones adventure with serialized network drama appeal.

Despite a 54/100 Metacritic critic score and a solid 6.7/10 user rating, dwindling viewership during Season 2 prompted its cancellation. CBS shifted it to Paramount+ for the final season, where it quietly faded from public attention.

4th: American Gothic (2016)

CBS spent a hefty amount per episode creating American Gothic, a psychological thriller revolving around family secrets and hidden crimes. Dark, atmospheric, and filled with twists, it aimed to capture summer TV audiences.

Critics were lukewarm, giving it 51/100 on Metacritic and 6.8/10 from users. Despite some intrigue, audiences didn’t stick around for the slow-burn story. CBS canceled it after one season without much fanfare or demands for revival.

3rd: Jupiter’s Legacy (2021)

Netflix invested a massive $200 million ($240m/£190m today) into Jupiter’s Legacy, adapting the popular comic book. Lavish special effects, grand storytelling, and complex heroes were supposed to establish Netflix’s flagship superhero franchise.

However, weak writing and pacing issues resulted in a 45/100 Metacritic critic score and a 6.7/10 user rating. High costs versus middling interest made Netflix pull the plug after just one disappointing season despite major marketing efforts.

2nd: Awake (2012)

NBC’s Awake blended police procedural with a psychological thriller; it did not have a publicly released budget. Jason Isaacs starred as a detective living in two alternate realities following a tragic car accident.

Critics praised it (75/100 Metacritic score), and users rated it 8.0/10. Yet its complex premise confused audiences, leading to rapidly declining viewership. NBC canceled it after one stellar but bewildering season, leaving a loyal fanbase wanting more.

For another mind-bending journey, check out ‘Severance’ S2.

1st: Firefly (2002)

Fox spent around $2 million ($3m/£2.4m today) per episode on Firefly, Joss Whedon’s space-western masterpiece. Quirky characters, deep worldbuilding, and heartfelt storytelling made it beloved, despite the network’s erratic episode airing.

Critics rated it 63/100 on Metacritic, but user scores soared to 9.0/10. Low initial ratings and scheduling issues doomed it after one season.

Check out more fascinating TV insights and stories, including Stranger Things 5’s most shocking predictions.

Were any of these flops unfairly canceled? Share your opinion in the comments, we’d love to hear which ones you think deserved more.

Read More From This Brand:

• TV Shows That Deserved Another Season
• 10 TV Shows That Shared The Same Sets
• TV Show Crossovers That Took Viewers By Storm

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one.