Was this helpful?
Thumbs UP Thumbs Down

Sydney Sweeney refuses to discuss American Eagle ad controversy while at TIFF promoting ‘Christy’ movie


Partial view of two boxers in boxing gloves touching hands
Table of Contents
Sydney Sweeney is wearing a custom Monot dress, Jimmy Choo shoes.

Sydney Sweeney shuts down jeans ad questions at TIFF

Sydney Sweeney’s appearance at the Toronto International Film Festival had everyone talking, but not for the reasons you might expect. While promoting her new movie, Christy, the actress faced questions about her recent American Eagle campaign.

Instead of fueling the controversy, she drew a sharp line, making it clear she wasn’t there to discuss jeans. Her bold response left fans and critics curious about her choice and eager to see how she navigates the spotlight moving forward.

Sydney Sweeney smiling into the camera at an eevent.

Post-TIFF buzz centered on Christy

As the festival progressed, the buzz clearly revolved around Sweeney’s performance in Christy. Media and audiences praised her transformation and depth in portraying boxer Christy Martin.

Talk of the jeans controversy faded in comparison to the film’s emotional resonance. Public interest gravitated to her acting rather than the ad backlash.

Text sign showing controversy

The jeans ad ignites controversy

Back in July, American Eagle launched a campaign starring Sweeney, using a pun linking “jeans” and “genes.” Many accused the ad of promoting eugenic or white supremacist messaging, a serious cultural misstep.

The backlash spread fast online and sparked national debate. Critics argued its symbolism was tone-deaf in a fraught political climate.

Stats on screen

The ad’s commercial results

Despite vocal criticism, the campaign drove impressive sales and visibility for American Eagle. Sydney’s branded jeans sold out within a week, and jackets in a day.

The company reported one of its most profitable quarters ever, thanks to the buzz. A real commercial win amid controversy.

American Eagle Outfitters sign outside a store

American Eagle defends its campaign

The brand responded quickly, stating the campaign was always and only about jeans. Their statement emphasized inclusion and confidence for all who wear their jeans.

They underlined that no deeper genetic messaging was intended. The defense helped steer some attention back to the product, not politics.

Man is using laptop with black keys social media icons

Cultural critics weigh in

Social media and cultural outlets flagged the visuals and wordplay as racially charged. Academics and commentators noted echoes of past advertising misfires with symbolic undertones.

The campaign was compared to historical examples where beauty, race, and lineage overlapped uncomfortably. The discussion revealed how quickly marketing tactics can cross cultural lines.

Closeup of microphones of different tv media.

Conservatives push back on backlash

Conservative voices framed criticism as “cancel culture” run amok. Some political figures and right-leaning media mocked the backlash and celebrated the ad as appealing and bold.

Former President Trump even called it the “HOTTEST ad out there,” fueling partisan reaction. The ad became a flashpoint in America’s culture wars.

No More written on a bag.

TIFF provides a clean break

At TIFF on September 5, Sweeney presented Christy without addressing the denim drama. She said plainly, “I’m not there to talk about jeans.”

She underscored that her sole priority was the film and the story of Christy Martin. The festival presented a chance to shift the narrative entirely to her craft.

Makeup

Her transformation for Christy

To play Christy Martin, Sweeney gained more than 30 pounds, wore brown contacts and a wig, and trained rigorously in boxing. Her physical change went beyond makeup; it was full immersion in the role.

Critics noted her commitment elevated the performance. Her transformation became a key element of festival praise.

Partial view of two boxers in boxing gloves touching hands

Story of Christy Martin

Christy tells the compelling story of boxer Christy Martin, who rose from West Virginia to fame in the 1990s and faced a violent personal struggle. She survived an attempted murder by her husband in 2010 and ultimately found healing and strength.

The film highlights her resilience and trailblazing role for women in sports. Sweeney said Martin’s tale was among the most inspiring she’d ever encountered.

An Oscar award

Oscar buzz begins

Sweeney’s performance received a standing ovation at TIFF and quickly sparked Oscar talk. Critics applauded how she disappeared into the character.

The film’s emotional weight and her transformation made her a contender in awards season discussions. For many, Christy is her most ambitious work yet.

Paparazzi people taking picture

Red-carpet elegance

For the premiere, Sweeney wore a light pink Erdem gown with red accents and subtle glam styling. Her look exuded sophistication and radiated on the TIFF red carpet.

It complemented the serious tone of the film while showcasing her star power. Fashion media praised her choice as fitting and elegant.

A young man in a black t-shirt showing a sign of thumb down

Stepping past the denim drama

By keeping answers focused on Christy, Sweeney controlled the narrative at TIFF. She declared clearly that jeans were nowhere near her radar at the festival.

That bold stance helped steer press coverage toward her work, not controversy. It was an effective move in managing media waves.

The concept of strategy.

Impact on American Eagle and retail

The controversy may have unsettled some customers, but foot traffic dipped after launch, overall sales rose, and brand awareness surged. American Eagle celebrated new customer acquisition and engagement.

The campaign was ultimately treated internally as a strategic reset. Its lasting impact on growth was significant.

TikTok social media application icon on a mobile screen.

TikTok trends and cultural ripple

A viral “good genes” TikTok trend emerged among college sororities, turning the campaign into content fodder. The ad spilled over from fashion to meme culture quickly.

That gave it extra reach and visibility beyond traditional marketing. It spoke to the modern cycle of viral amplification.

In other news, Tom Cruise dealt a major setback to Donald Trump by reportedly turning down the Kennedy Center honor.

Excited young adults share and react to content on social media.

Public reaction shifts

Fans and critics alike responded warmly to her performance, overshadowing earlier backlash. Social media commentary praised her portrayal, labeling it powerful and immersive.

Public sentiment leaned more positive toward her craft than any marketing misfire. The moment felt like a reset for her public image.

Talking about internet buzz, controversy forces the cancellation of Howard Stern’s comeback.

Do you think Sydney was right to keep the focus on her film? Share your thoughts in the comments, and don’t forget to like.

Read More From This Brand:

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.

This is exclusive content for our subscribers

Enter your email address to subscribe and get instant FREE access to all of our articles

Was this helpful?
Thumbs UP Thumbs Down
Prev Next
Share this post

Lucky you! This thread is empty,
which means you've got dibs on the first comment.
Go for it!

Send feedback to NashvilleGab

Close Feedback Form



    We appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback about this page with us.

    Whether it's praise for something good, or ideas to improve something that isn't quite right, we're excited to hear from you.