Scarlett Johansson reveals first date antics almost ended romance

An awkward first date memory

Scarlett Johansson recently shared details of her first date with Colin Jost, admitting it was unexpectedly awkward. She recalled attending the date while guest-cohosting Today with Jenna & Friends on December 1, 2025.

The outing took place in 2017 at an Italian restaurant in New York’s East Village. What started as a pleasant dinner soon turned into a moment of panic for Johansson.

Dinner began smoothly

According to Johansson, the date started lovely, she and Jost had dinner at around 8 p.m. in a cozy Italian spot. She described the meal as pleasant, suggesting the initial environment felt comfortable.

For a moment, everything seemed normal and promising. That positive start made what followed all the more unexpected.

Things turned awkward afterwards

After dinner, Jost invited Johansson to join his friends for drinks, a common, relaxed continuation of a date. But Johansson said she felt overwhelmed: she wasn’t used to traditional dating.

She said she was a serial monogamist and had never before been asked out in the conventional sense. That unfamiliarity triggered discomfort.

Sudden exit causes confusion

Instead of staying out, Johansson abruptly ended the evening. She told Jost she had to leave and left the restaurant.

When she arrived home around 9:36 PM to relieve her babysitter, the sitter asked why she was back so early. The early return raised questions, even her babysitter was puzzled.

Johansson felt flustered and panicked

During the date, Johansson admitted that she “panicked.” She explained that the sudden request to meet a group of friends right after dinner felt overwhelming and completely unexpected.

The shift in plans made her anxious, and she recalled thinking she needed to leave because she wasn’t sure how to navigate the situation without feeling out of place. Johansson said the moment caught her off guard, leaving her internally scrambling for a graceful way out.

Jost assumed the night was over

From Jost’s perspective, Johansson’s abrupt exit came across as disinterested. He later admitted that he assumed the date had gone nowhere. Johansson recalled him saying, I totally thought that was it, you were acting so weird.

In that moment, he genuinely believed their connection hadn’t landed and that their relationship probably wouldn’t move forward.

Dating inexperience shaped the moment

Johansson explained that she had rarely participated in what most people consider typical dating. She described herself as someone who tended to move directly from one long-term relationship to another, rather than spending time on casual dates or early-stage courtship.

Because of that pattern, the dynamics of a “normal” first date felt unfamiliar and a little unsettling to her. That background, she noted, helps clarify why she reacted nervously that evening and why the situation felt more overwhelming than it might for someone used to traditional dating experiences.

Honesty about vulnerability

By sharing this memory publicly, Johansson allowed fans a glimpse into her vulnerability, admitting that despite fame, she sometimes struggles with ordinary experiences. The candidness humanizes her, showing she isn’t immune to insecurity or social discomfort.

It’s rare for celebrities to reveal such honest feelings about early romance. Her recollection resonates with people who’ve felt awkward on first dates.

Romance survived the rocky start

Despite that rocky first date, Johansson and Jost didn’t give up on each other. They eventually began dating after that night in 2017.

Their relationship continued with patience and understanding, showing that first impressions, even awkward ones, don’t always determine outcomes. Their story illustrates that love can survive early missteps.

Their love endured into marriage

Scarlett Johansson and Colin Jost married in October 2020, marking a new chapter that followed years of growing closeness. Since their wedding, they have built a steady family life together and later welcomed a son, reinforcing the strength of their partnership.

Their successful marriage underscores that early misunderstandings or awkward moments didn’t hinder the development of a long-term bond. Instead, their eventual happiness highlights how genuine connection, mutual respect, and emotional clarity can outweigh a rocky beginning.

First impressions aren’t everything

Johansson’s revelation serves as a reminder that first impressions, especially in dating, aren’t always accurate predictors of future happiness. Nervousness, inexperience, or discomfort don’t imply lack of interest or compatibility.

Her story suggests that giving yourself and others another chance can lead to great relationships. It’s a hopeful message for anyone who’s ever struggled in early dating moments.

Public honesty fosters connection

By honestly sharing an awkward past moment, Johansson connects with fans on a human level. It breaks down celebrity mystique, showing that even public figures face relatable social anxieties.

Many fans responded with empathy and admiration for her openness. That kind of real-life honesty builds trust and relatability beyond glamour.

Public honesty fosters connection, just as Scarlett Johansson’s upfront story about her co-star kiss led to a heartfelt reaction from Colin Jost, proving that honesty can deepen understanding.

A reminder of love’s unpredictable start

Scarlett Johansson’s story underscores that love’s beginnings can be messy and uncertain, but that doesn’t mean they’re doomed. Even with a first date that felt weird and panicky, love can grow, mature, and thrive.

Her journey with Colin Jost shows that patience, second chances, and authenticity matter more than perfect first impressions. Their enduring marriage stands as a real-life example of resilience, understanding, and hope.

Just as love can begin in the most unexpected ways, Scarlett Johansson’s record-breaking SNL episode proved that surprises and unforgettable moments can happen when you least expect them.

What’s your most memorable or unexpected first-date moment? Share your experience in the comments.

Read More From This Brand:

• Scarlett Johansson’s Surprising Reaction to Justin Baldoni’s Mention in Vanity Fair Interview
• After decades of friendship Reba McEntire and Rex Linn are officially engaged
• Jennifer Lopez admits she’s keeping love life ‘quiet’ after heartbreak

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.