Scarlett Johansson and Jack Antonoff’s high school relationship is back in the spotlight

A blast from the past

Celebrity throwbacks always get people talking, and this one comes with real high school history. Scarlett Johansson and Jack Antonoff are back in the conversation because an old class photo reminded fans that they were once teenage sweethearts.

The image brought attention to a relationship many people had forgotten. It also tied together their school days, their prom memories, and the way one old photo can suddenly make a private chapter feel current again.

The classmates behind the photo

Scarlett Johansson, Jack Antonoff, and Christy Carlson Romano all attended the Professional Children’s School in New York City.

The school brought together young performers, and the resurfaced image shows how closely their paths crossed before any of them reached their later career milestones.

The photo came from the class of 2002. That detail matters because it places Johansson and Antonoff in the same graduating circle and underscores that their connection was rooted in shared school life.

Why fans are talking now

The renewed interest started when Christy Carlson Romano posted an Instagram gallery filled with throwback moments from her life. She used the post to promote her memoir, Once Upon a Trainwreck: The Rise and Fall of a Child Star, which is set for release on October 6, 2026.

Among the family and childhood photos was a high school class picture featuring Johansson and Antonoff. That single image quickly pulled attention away from the wider gallery and turned an old teen romance into a fresh celebrity conversation.

A staircase shot that says a lot

The yearbook image shows Johansson and Antonoff standing at the top of a staircase with classmates around them.

Romano appears smiling to the right, which gives the picture an even stronger sense of class reunion energy rather than a random celebrity flashback.

One small detail made people look twice. Antonoff has his hand on Johansson’s shoulder, and that simple pose gave the photo an unmistakably personal feel that matched the long-reported story of their high school relationship.

Little-known fact: Scarlett Johansson released an album of mostly Tom Waits covers, a surprise move many fans still don’t know about.

They were more than classmates

Johansson and Antonoff were not just students at the same school. They were high school sweethearts, and that part of their story has followed them for years whenever old photos or dating timelines from the early 2000s resurface.

Their relationship included milestone moments that made it feel especially real to fans. News that they went to prom together helped cement the idea that this was a true teenage romance, not just a passing rumor tied to famous names.

Their prom still stands out

Their prom connection became public years later, when it was reported in 2014 that the two had attended prom together. That detail gave fans a very clear picture of how serious their young relationship seemed during their final school years.

Prom carries a very specific meaning in American culture, and that is part of why the story keeps resurfacing. It turns two future stars into recognizable teens with the same kind of memory many readers associate with their own high school years.

Fun fact: Scarlett Johansson has said she dislikes the nickname “ScarJo,” calling it lazy and even a little insulting despite how often it appears in pop culture.

The breakup became part of the story

The romance did not last beyond those school years. Reports later said the two broke up shortly after graduation, adding another detail to the story of their high school relationship.

Later coverage framed the breakup as a meaningful part of Antonoff’s early personal history. The emotional angle gave the relationship a longer life in public memory, because people tend to remember young love stories even more when music and lingering feelings become part of them.

A song kept the romance alive

In 2005, Antonoff and his band Steel Train released “Better Love,” and the song has long been speculated to be about Johansson. That idea kept their old relationship in the public conversation long after their school days had ended.

The lyrics helped fuel that interpretation. Lines mentioning “Scarlett” and another that appears to nod to Girl with a Pearl Earring led listeners to connect the song to Johansson almost immediately.

Why the lyrics drew attention

The song did not just hint at heartbreak in general. It included lines that made the connection feel unusually pointed, which is why people kept returning to it whenever Johansson and Antonoff’s early romance came up in conversation.

The ending added another layer to that reaction. A bittersweet line about missing her years later made the track feel less like a vague breakup song and more like a lingering emotional record from a very specific time in Antonoff’s life.

Antonoff later had regrets

The attention around the song eventually became a burden of its own. Steel Train bassist Matt Goldman said Antonoff sometimes wished he had not included such an obvious reference because people kept asking about Johansson instead of focusing on the band itself.

That comment changed how some fans saw the track. It suggested that what may have felt honest or dramatic at the time later became something Antonoff could not easily separate from interviews and questions about his past.

Romano’s post had other memories too

The throwback gallery was not focused only on Johansson and Antonoff. Romano also included other personal photos, including a picture with Hilary Duff and Haylie Duff, as well as family images and the cover of her upcoming memoir.

That broader context makes the post feel more personal than it would on its own. It was built as a look back at different parts of her life, but the class photo with Johansson and Antonoff quickly became the detail that sparked the biggest reaction.

All three went on different paths

The old class photo is striking because it captures three young performers before their adult careers fully took shape. Romano, Johansson, and Antonoff all moved into very different lanes in entertainment, which makes the school connection feel even more interesting now.

Johansson later became a two-time Oscar nominee, while Antonoff earned major recognition in music, including Grammy wins. Romano built her own screen career and is now revisiting her past through a memoir that unexpectedly reopened this shared chapter.

Curious why Scarlett Johansson’s name is suddenly tied to The Batman 2? See what Scarlett Johansson’s negotiation secret for The Batman 2 fuels urgent buzz after Zoe Kravitz’s exit could mean for the casting talk.

Where they are now

The resurfaced photo looks back at a teenage romance, but both stars have long since moved into different stages of life. Antonoff is now married to actress Margaret Qualley, while Johansson is married to Colin Jost.

That contrast is part of what makes the story land so well today. The photo freezes one early moment from 2002, while the people in it have grown into public figures whose lives now look completely different from that staircase scene.

Want the fuller context behind her comments? Check out what Scarlett Johansson reflects on the challenges of supporting Woody Allen and publicly breaks down why the issue still draws attention.

That contrast is what makes the moment so striking today. Does seeing a celebrity romance from 2002 make the story more memorable for you? Share your thoughts in the comments.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

Read More From This Brand:

• Scarlett Johansson dragged into Blake Lively–Justin Baldoni legal battle after audio leak
• Scarlett Johansson loses highest-paid actress crown, Colin Jost quips
• Colin Jost’s reaction to Scarlett Johansson being dethroned is winning over fans