Martin Short on ‘Only Murders in the Building’ future and passing on ‘Match Game’

Only Murders in the Building approaches potential conclusion

Martin Short recently hinted that Only Murders in the Building season five could mark the show’s final chapter. He expressed surprise that the series has maintained its quality and popularity for this duration in the competitive streaming landscape.

Short compared the show’s potential ending to classic television series that concluded at their creative peak. “I think that the reality is, you know when it feels like it’s past its time,” Short observed regarding the show’s future.

Match Game hosting duties

ABC selected Martin Short to host the revived Match Game following Alec Baldwin’s five season tenure that ended in 2021. Short brings decades of improvisational comedy experience to the classic game show format.

The transition represents a natural evolution for the series while maintaining its signature comedic atmosphere. Short’s selection reflects his proven ability to engage celebrity panelists and contestants with spontaneous humor and professional charm.

Season five investigates doorman Lester’s mysterious death

Only Murders in the Building season five premieres September 9, 2025, featuring the suspicious death of beloved doorman Lester. The investigation expands beyond the familiar Arconia building into dangerous criminal territory throughout New York City.

Charles, Oliver, and Mabel discover connections between powerful billionaires, traditional organized crime figures, and mysterious building residents. This storyline represents the series’ most ambitious scope, exploring contemporary urban power dynamics.

Criminal investigation reveals dangerous web

The trio’s investigation into Lester’s death uncovers a complex network involving established criminal organizations and emerging dangerous players. Showrunner John Hoffman describes the season as examining “classic meets modern” themes within New York’s criminal landscape.

The expanded mystery takes the characters into “shadowy corners of New York and beyond” as they navigate unfamiliar territory. This departure from cozy apartment building mysteries challenges the trio with higher stakes and greater personal risk.

Celebrity panelists

Match Game features an impressive roster of celebrity guests, including Short’s Only Murders in the Building costar Selena Gomez. The panel combines returning favorites with fresh comedic personalities to maintain the show’s signature cocktail party atmosphere.

Short serves as both host and executive producer, carefully selecting panelists who contribute to spontaneous humor rather than scripted responses. His casting choices reflect understanding of what makes effective panel dynamics work within the classic format.

Streaming platform longevity surprises veteran performer

Short has expressed amazement that Only Murders in the Building has survived five years in the competitive streaming environment. He notes that streaming shows typically don’t achieve the longevity of traditional television programs from previous decades.

“This is a long time in streaming to go five years,” Short commented about the show’s duration. His perspective reflects industry awareness of how content consumption patterns have dramatically changed in the modern entertainment landscape.

Hulu’s most watched comedy

Only Murders in the Building currently holds impressive ratings with a 97% critics score on Rotten Tomatoes and 90% audience approval. The series has earned recognition as Hulu’s most-watched comedy series ever, demonstrating its exceptional popularity across demographics.

The show received 21 Emmy nominations, with Short earning multiple Lead Actor nominations throughout its run. This critical recognition validates the series’ unique blend of mystery and comedy that distinguishes it from other television offerings.

Oliver Putnam character

Short’s portrayal of struggling Broadway director Oliver Putnam benefits from his extensive theatrical background and industry understanding. The character’s show business insights and theatrical references reflect genuine knowledge gained through decades of stage performance.

Oliver’s personality combines theatrical ambition with comedic vulnerability, creating a relatable character despite his eccentric tendencies. Short’s Tony Award winning performance in Little Me and other Broadway credits inform his authentic portrayal of the entertainment industry insider.

New York setting provides authentic backdrop

The Arconia apartment building serves as more than just a location, functioning as a character itself within the series narrative. Only Murders in the Building showcases classic Manhattan architecture and neighborhood dynamics that resonate with longtime city residents and newcomers alike.

Season five explores how traditional New York institutions like doorman positions represent important cultural heritage within the city’s evolving landscape. The setting grounds fantastical murder mysteries in realistic urban environments that audiences recognize and appreciate.

Steve Martin partnership continues decades long creative collaboration

Martin Short and Steve Martin’s professional relationship spans multiple decades, beginning with Three Amigos and continuing through the Father of the Bride films. Their collaboration in Only Murders in the Building showcases remarkable comedic chemistry built on genuine friendship.

Short has praised Martin’s character and loyalty as foundational elements of their enduring partnership. The duo’s relationship demonstrates how authentic friendship can enhance rather than complicate professional collaborations in competitive entertainment industry environments.

Emmy recognition validates creative achievement

Short has received four consecutive Emmy nominations for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series since the show’s debut. This sustained recognition highlights his consistent performance quality and the character’s development throughout the series’ progression.

The nominations reflect both individual achievement and the show’s overall creative success within the competitive comedy television landscape. Short’s recognition validates his transition from sketch comedy and film work to contemporary streaming television excellence.

Match Game format emphasizes spontaneous humor

The revived Match Game prioritizes improvisational comedy and genuine celebrity reactions rather than prepared responses. Short has emphasized that the show succeeds when interactions feel natural and conversations develop organically between participants.

“It’s pretty free form. Certainly the questions are written and the game itself is structured, but everything else is in the moment,” Short explained. This approach maintains the series’ traditional atmosphere while allowing celebrity personalities to shine through authentic interaction.

Comedy legend status enables seamless transitions

Short’s career demonstrates exceptional versatility across sketch comedy, films, Broadway productions, TV series, and game show hosting responsibilities. His foundation in improvisational comedy provides transferable skills applicable to various entertainment formats.

The performer’s energy and character development abilities translate effectively from SCTV and Saturday Night Live to contemporary streaming television success. This adaptability has enabled him to remain culturally relevant across multiple decades of industry evolution.

Gene Rayburn’s hosting legacy

Gene Rayburn hosted Match Game from 1962 to 1984, establishing the show’s distinctive blend of wit, wordplay, and cocktail party atmosphere. His ability to connect with contestants and celebrities while managing chaos became the template for successful game show hosting techniques.

Short has expressed admiration for Rayburn’s style, particularly his skill at making complex interactions appear effortless and entertaining. The legendary host’s approach emphasized spontaneous humor over scripted comedy.

Doorman murder mystery explores contemporary urban themes

Season five addresses shifting power structures in New York City, examining how traditional institutions compete with modern challenges and threats. The storyline grounds the comedy mystery in realistic urban issues.

Showrunner John Hoffman describes the narrative as exploring “very specific questions about the balance of power in New York”. This approach allows the series to comment on contemporary social issues without losing its fundamental appeal as escapist entertainment programming.

Want to know what’s next for the show? Check out the latest updates on Only Murders in the Building season 5.

Host replacement represents significant career milestone

Taking over Match Game hosting duties from Alec Baldwin represents both opportunity and challenge for Short’s diverse career portfolio. The transition demonstrates his continued relevance in contemporary television while honoring classic game show traditions and audience expectations.

Short’s appointment reflects network confidence in his ability to maintain the show’s popularity while bringing fresh energy to established formats. This hosting role adds another dimension to his already impressive resume spanning multiple entertainment mediums and generations of audiences.

Netflix cancels four shows and confirms final seasons for fan favorites, causing buzz over social media.

Are you excited to see what’s next for Only Murders in the Building after Martin Short’s tease?

Read More From This Brand:

• Hulu’s Best Upcoming Original Movies You Should Not Miss
• Cant Miss TV Shows Currently On Hulu
• Top Romance Films on Hulu Perfect for Every Mood

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.