Josh O’Connor plays a murder suspect alongside Daniel Craig in a new trailer

A dark secret in the pews

When you picture a peaceful church, you don’t usually imagine a shocking murder. But in the new Knives Out teaser, Daniel Craig’s detective Benoit Blanc arrives in a quiet parish to face his trickiest case yet, with Josh O’Connor right in the middle of it.

We learn O’Connor plays Reverend Jud Duplenticy, who’s under suspicion for the death of a powerful monsignor. Together with Blanc, he’s thrust into a web of secrets, faith, and betrayal.

Old church, new mystery

The trailer sets the scene in a small, stone church deep in upstate New York. The church has a devoted congregation, and the teaser hints at secrets and tension within the parish.

That peaceful facade cracks when Monsignor Jefferson Wicks, a respected church figure, is found dead under impossible circumstances, locked room, no obvious killer.

O’Connor takes a risky role

Josh O’Connor, known for roles like Prince Charles in The Crown, steps into the shoes of a conflicted priest. His character, Jud Duplenticy, is introduced as calm and spiritual.

But things get complicated: he becomes a prime suspect in Wicks’ mysterious death, raising questions about trust, faith, and guilt. As the investigation deepens, Duplenticy’s gentle image starts to look more complicated, and the tension around him grows stronger.

Blanc is back and is sharper than ever

Daniel Craig comes back as Benoit Blanc, the brilliant detective known for his soft Southern drawl and uncanny insight. He walks into this mystery not just confident, but deeply aware that something about the case is off.

Nothing here makes sense; the clues are confusing, motives are hidden, and every door seems locked, yet the crime feels too neat to be simple. Blanc’s calm reasoning meets a puzzle that demands all of his experience, and he’s clearly ready to dig deeper than ever before.

Small‑town power runs deep

In this tight-knit church community, power isn’t just about religion, it’s about influence, reputation, and long-buried secrets. Everyone in the parish seems to have something at stake: some fear scandal, others crave respect, and a few may even hold grudges.

For Blanc, navigating this world is more than just solving a crime. He must read between the lines of prayers and sermons, detecting not just what people say but what they fear.

A surprising lineup of suspects

The suspect list is star‑studded: alongside Craig and Josh O’Connor, the film features Josh Brolin, Mila Kunis, Glenn Close, Jeremy Renner, Kerry Washington, Andrew Scott, Cailee Spaeny, Daryl McCormack, and Thomas Haden Church.

Each name brings a different energy and potential motive, adding real weight to every part they play. This is not a small, forgettable cast, it’s a gathering of heavy hitters, each with their own storyline and secrets.

Where faith meets suspicion

Religion isn’t just decoration here; it’s central to the conflict. The church setting isn’t only spiritual; it’s political, emotional, and deeply personal. Reverence and doubt live side by side, as church leaders and believers wrestle with the implications of a crime committed in a holy place.

That tension between sacred trust and hidden sin gives the story extra weight. Blanc and the suspect, Reverend Duplenticy, don’t just debate facts; they challenge ideas of forgiveness, guilt, and redemption.

A chamber sealed by mystery

The trailer reveals a chilling locked-room: the room where the monsignor died seems impossible to enter or exit. Doors are closed, windows are sealed, yet somehow, a murder took place. That classic locked-room scenario instantly raises the stakes, giving Blanc his most puzzling challenge yet.

This kind of puzzle feels like one from the golden age of detective fiction, where logic must outthink the impossibility. Blanc must combine sharp observation, creative reasoning, and courage to understand how someone could have committed such a crime.

Duplenticy’s burden of doubt

Josh O’Connor’s character, Reverend Jud Duplenticy, carries a heavy load. He’s young, sincere, and deeply committed to his faith, but now he’s facing a devastating accusation that threatens everything he believes in.

The church trusted him, his congregation loved him, and now people are watching him with suspicion. Though he cries innocence, the weight of doubt presses in from all sides. Secrets around him begin to surface, and the more Blanc investigates, the more complicated his life becomes.

An unlikely detective partnership

Blanc doesn’t go it alone. He teams up with Geraldine Scott, the local police chief played by Mila Kunis, to tackle this deeply tangled mystery. She brings law‑and‑order grit, experience, and a cautious approach, while he brings intuition, theatrics, and unconventional methods.

Their styles are totally different, but that actually helps. Where she demands procedure and facts, he reads silence and body language.

Hidden truths behind pious faces

Inside the church’s walls, every character seems calm, devout, and devoted, but appearances can lie. From the groundskeeper to the legal adviser, from parishioners to elders, everyone may be hiding something under their vestments and prayers.

Blanc’s investigation peels back these layers slowly, exposing motivations and secrets. The mystery isn’t just who committed the crime, but why someone would do such a thing in a place of faith.

A case that hits close to home

For Blanc, this investigation isn’t just about catching a killer; it resonates personally. The crime doesn’t just challenge his detective skills; it challenges his core beliefs about justice, redemption, and human nature.

As he digs deeper, he realizes the truth might be more devastating than he expected. This isn’t a simple murder to him; it’s a reflection of human frailty, pride, and hope, and solving it may force everyone involved to face truths they’ve long hidden.

If you’re interested in mysteries shaped by emotion and hidden truths, you’ll love how the new ‘only murders in the Building’ star, Selena Gomez, once had a crush on, explores personal stakes behind the scenes.

Mark your calendars

Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery opens in theaters on November 26, then premieres on Netflix on December 12. This gives you two great ways to see it, either on the big screen or from the comfort of home.

If you love clever puzzles, emotionally charged mysteries, and a detective who’s as charming as he is smart, this could easily be one of your favorite whodunits. With a cast full of big names and a story full of faith, guilt, and tricky clues, it promises to keep you guessing until the very end.

Fans of clever clues and character-driven puzzles in Wake Up Dead Man may enjoy reading about Netflix’s plans for Thursday Murder Club and whether a sequel is on the way.

Which one are you more excited about, Wake Up Dead Man or Thursday Murder Club? Share your thoughts in the comments!

Read More From This Brand:

• Martin Short on ‘Only Murders in the Building’ future and passing on ‘Match Game’
• Only Murders In The Building season 5 updates
• Mystery solved: Jamie Lee Curtis confirms ‘Murder, She Wrote’ reboot is officially in the works

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.