Jennifer Love Hewitt joins ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer’ sequel

The Final Girl Returns for One Last Summer

Jennifer Love Hewitt is back, and so is the hook. As whispers of a deadly secret spread once more, the upcoming sequel to I Know What You Did Last Summer promises chills, nostalgia, and a brutal new twist.

With legacy stars returning and fresh faces joining the fray, this isn’t just another horror reboot, it’s a reckoning. Here’s what’s coming, and why fans can’t stop talking.

Legacy Meets New Blood

The sequel introduces a fresh group of young adults who are involved in a fatal hit-and-run and must grapple with guilt and mystery after a year of fear. To survive the terror, they seek help from Julie James and Ray Bronson, portrayed by Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr., respectively, bringing a mentor–mentee dynamic into the mix.

This setup mirrors the original’s structure while updating it for a modern audience, blending classic slasher tropes with new suspense. Director Jennifer Kaytin Robinson intentionally crafted this mix, citing inspiration from franchise revivals like Scream.

Returning Together

Jennifer Love Hewitt wasn’t the only one returning; Freddie Prinze Jr. is also back as Ray Bronson, marking the first time both legacy stars have appeared together in the franchise since the early 2000s.

Their reunion was not a mere cameo, but rather a substantial part of the plot where they guide the new generation through the horrors of their own past actions. Prinze Jr. described their return as the “best work we’ve done” in the franchise, showing how invested they both were in giving fans more than just nostalgia.

Emotional Reunion On Set

Hewitt described meeting Prinze Jr. again on set as a “high school reunion” with butterflies and excitement. She said they slipped right back into their original characters as if no time had passed, bringing a sense of authenticity to the production.

Their camaraderie helped them deliver emotionally resonant scenes, adding depth beyond mere scares. This old‑friends chemistry really shines, giving new life to their characters and anchoring the horror in real relationships.

Fame and Pressure

Returning to Julie James after nearly three decades brought real pressure for Hewitt, who admitted to feeling anxious for two days before filming. She wrestled with questions like “Can I still do this role justice?” after all this time.

Ultimately, she overcame her doubts, proving that a well-developed character can hold up when treated carefully. That pressure translated into performance, making her return meaningful rather than just nostalgic.

Directors and Creative Vision

Jennifer Kaytin Robinson takes the helm as director, co-writing the script alongside Sam Lansky, expanding the original slasher into a more brutal and emotionally driven story. Robinson aimed to honor franchise traditions while bringing a fresh voice, injecting unexpected twists and more intense gore.

Her vision includes both homage, like Julie’s memorable lines, and new aesthetic elements reminiscent of shows like Scream. She described filming scenes with Hewitt and Prinze Jr. as “crazy, out‑of-body,” given their star power and chemistry.

Iconic Lines Return

One of the most memorable callbacks in the franchise is the return of Julie James’s iconic line, “What are you waiting for?”, used to dramatic effect in both the April and June 2025 trailers. Hewitt and the team agreed that fans needed that moment, delivered with renewed intensity and fresh context.

She even prepared carefully the night before to deliver it differently than before, adding weight to a simple phrase. That moment serves as a bridge between nostalgia and the sequel’s new emotional core.

Filming Locations

Principal photography took place between October 2024 and March 2025 in New South Wales, Australia, and Los Angeles, California. Cinematographer Elisha Christian shot scenes that ranged from atmospheric seaside tension to dimly lit interiors, matching the tone of a modern slasher thriller.

Shooting across both hemispheres offered varied scenery and technical resources for the production. These locations gave the film fresh visuals while maintaining a coastal setting that fans recognize.

Gory and Brutal

Newsweek reports that the sequel raises the intensity, with horror “ratcheted up to a hundred” compared to the 1997 original. This means more visceral violence and stronger emotional shocks, pushing the franchise into new territory.

The goal was to balance old fans’ expectations with demands from new audiences for real thrills. Jennifer Kaytin Robinson pushed for scenes that make viewers feel unsettled, but still keep the narrative clever.

Expanded Cast

Along with legacy stars, the sequel introduces a new ensemble: Madelyn Cline, Chase Sui Wonders, Jonah Hauer‑King, Tyriq Withers, Sarah Pidgeon, Gabbriette Bechtel, Austin Nichols, Billy Campbell, Lola Tung, and Nicholas Alexander Chavez. They play five friends and supporting characters, each with different backgrounds and motivations.

Their diverse personalities, college student, podcaster, preacher’s kin, add depth and interwoven drama. All face the consequences of covering up a hit‑and‑run, uniting them in fear and guilt.

Plot Setup

The plot begins with a fatal hit-and-run committed by the new group, who panic and cover it up to avoid jail and shame. A year later, a hook‑wielding stalker begins sending chilling messages, echoing the fears of the past.

Julie and Ray, survivors of the original incident, return to guide and warn them as the horror intensifies. Past trauma fuels present danger, creating a layered narrative about guilt, memory, and revenge.

Ray’s New Role

Freddie Prinze Jr.’s character, Ray Bronson, now runs a bar in Southport, giving him a grounded, grizzled presence. Prinze noted that Ray’s more vulnerable side shows up when chaos returns, revealing emotional scars from his past and his love for Julie.

This complexity means Ray is a multifaceted ally, not just a relic from the past. His journey illustrates how trauma lingers and how people cope when faced with it again.

Emotional Arcs

Director Robinson emphasized that both Julie and Ray need catharsis through helping the younger cast members face their guilt. Their own buried pain gets stirred up, creating tension between mentoring and needing help themselves.

The younger group also has emotional arcs tied to their secrets and fears. Together, they form a web of trauma, growth, and support against a killer bent on revenge.

Survivor Themes

The sequel explores how Julie and Ray became “survivors,” not perfect, but living with past scars. Julie is now a trauma professor, showing she has become an expert at healing others while still dealing with her own fears.

Her role reflects growth and depth. Ray’s bar‑owner life shows how he tried to build something steady after chaos.

In other news, the Secret Lives of Mormon Wives reunion special drops on Hulu.

TV Series Tie‑in

While there was a 2021 Amazon Prime series, it was canceled after one season and doesn’t connect to this sequel. Sony rebooted the movie storyline with this standalone legacy sequel, ignoring the TV timeline.

That decision lets the film focus on cinematic storytelling rooted in the original films. It also reassures fans that continuity stays within the theatrical franchise.

If you’re looking to fill the gap until the release of the sequel, check out Hulu’s lineup of best upcoming original movies you shouldn’t miss; there’s plenty to keep you hooked.

What do you think will unfold in the sequel? Let us know your thoughts!

Read More From This Brand:

• Taylor Swift’s Rhode Island Mansion Soars in Value
• Why is The Ballad of Wallis Island a Major Hit?
• Actors Who Disliked Their Own TV Shows

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.