NashvilleGab - Jennifer Love Hewitt hasn’t spoken to Sarah Michelle Gellar since she was 18

s_bukley/Depositphotos

Where did the friendship go?

Jennifer Love Hewitt just made a surprising confession that’s left fans buzzing. While promoting the revival of I Know What You Did Last Summer, she revealed something about her relationship with co-star Sarah Michelle Gellar that no one saw coming.

The internet exploded with theories, but what’s the real story behind their long silence? Let’s take a closer look at what’s been stirring beneath the surface all these years.

[email protected]/Depositphotos

An unexpected topic emerges

The spotlight recently shifted to a surprising claim about Jennifer Love Hewitt and Sarah Michelle Gellar. In an interview, Hewitt confessed she hasn’t spoken to Gellar since she was 18, when the original I Know What You Did Last Summer premiered.

This revelation surprised many fans because they grew up seeing these actresses as close friends. The buzz around this claim shows how deeply fans connect with the actors beyond their onscreen roles.

Depositphotos

A 28‑year silence

Hewitt, now 46, revealed she hasn’t talked to Gellar in 28 years. That timeline takes us back to 1997, the year I Know What You Did Last Summer hit theaters.

According to Hewitt, this lack of contact does not reflect ill feelings on her part; it’s just been the nature of their lives. That reminder surprised people who assumed the silence meant tension.

Depositphotos

Hewitt speaks out

In her Vulture interview, Hewitt joked that she doesn’t even know where the feud rumors come from. She asked, “Why do we always have to be against each other?” indicating she finds the scenario absurd.

She insisted she holds no bitterness toward Gellar. She clearly stressed that from her perspective, “On my side, we’re good.”

Closeup of microphones of different tv media.

Depositphotos

Media breathes fire

Despite her clear stance, the media jumped on the silence and spun it as a feud just like it always does. Headlines screamed about a “bitter rivalry” despite no real evidence.

Fans soon filled online forums with speculation and rumors. This reaction shows how quickly media can shape celebrity narratives.

A hand surfing on social media with friend request icons.

Depositphotos

Gellar addresses it publicly

Sarah Michelle Gellar responded via Instagram, saying she just “never got to see” Hewitt on red carpet day. She explained she spent time inside with her kids and didn’t even attend the after‑party.

Gellar praised Hewitt’s performance and clarified their lack of interaction was coincidental. She referred to the so‑called feud as something that only exists online.

Close up of calendar page on office desk.

Depositphotos

At the premiere

Both attended the premiere of the new sequel on July 14, yet didn’t cross paths visibly due to some circumstances. Photos didn’t show them together on the red carpet, prompting fans to scream “feud!”.

Gellar addressed that directly, saying she wasn’t avoiding Hewitt. The premiere’s chaotic environment simply kept them apart.

Depositphotos

Franchise legacy returns

The reason this topic caught fire again is tied to the new sequel. Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr. both reprised their roles in the 2025 revival. Gellar surprised fans with a brief dream‑sequence cameo as Helen Shivers.

That reunion, albeit short, sparked questions about their off‑camera relationship and how bonded the two cast members actually were.

Long red carpet between rope barriers on entrance

Depositphotos

Hewitt on her red‑carpet look

While addressing relationship rumors, Hewitt also caught attention with her new red hair. She dubbed the shade “Sunset Lover,” and fans loved this new look on the actress.

Her cool look won praise from celebs like Alyssa Milano and Tommy DiDario. That positive buzz helped shift the conversation beyond rumored drama.

Cropped view of woman holding speech bubble with question mark.

Depositphotos

Why the feud rumors spread

It’s interesting how silence and photos can cause speculation and turn something simple into a feud. In their case, a single missed photo op didn’t mean hostility; it was just logistics.

Add in social media, and suddenly mute moments sound like fireworks. That illustrates how little evidence is needed to create a viral narrative.

Man is using laptop with black keys social media icons

Depositphotos

Fans took a stand

Fans were quick to defend both actresses. Many praised Gellar’s clear clarification that she thinks Hewitt “was fantastic in the movie.”

Others rushed to defend Hewitt’s feelings, showing support for her honesty and straightening things out. Their response demonstrates the passion and loyalty visible in fan communities.

A young man in a black t-shirt showing a sign of thumb down

Depositphotos

Both deny any rivalry

All evidence coming out shows both are denying any rift. Hewitt says she “literally” hasn’t spoken to Gellar since she was 18.

Gellar confirms she missed seeing Hewitt because of event logistics, not drama, which the media has supposedly conjured up. They both emphasize there’s no rivalry, just lives that drifted apart.

Depositphotos

What happened in 1997

Back in 1997, Hewitt was just 18 and playing Julie James, while Gellar played Helen Shivers. That movie introduced a group of teens dealing with suspense and guilt.

Helen’s character died in a dramatic scene, a moment that became iconic. It’s easy to forget how young they were and how long ago it all began

criminal minds tv series poster on disney plus site criminal

egunes_/Depositphotos

Career paths diverged

After the original film, their careers took different turns. Hewitt went on to star in Ghost Whisperer, Criminal Minds, and 9‑1‑1. Gellar became best known for Buffy the Vampire Slayer and ventured into family life.

They stayed in touch with Hollywood but chose different kinds of roles. That divergence likely contributed to their natural distance.