‘I Know What You Did Last Summer’ review

The Fisherman returns with a vengeance

The hook is back, and so is the mystery. I Know What You Did Last Summer returns in 2025 with a bold new take that’s catching attention from both longtime fans and curious newcomers.

Packed with secrets, screams, and surprises, this new chapter dives into the deadly consequences of one unforgettable night. But is it just a nostalgia trip, or something more?

Introduction to the 2025 legacy sequel

This new installment, released July 18, 2025, revives the franchise by blending nostalgia and fresh characters in a slasher format set nearly three decades after the original. It’s directed by Jennifer Kaytin Robinson and picks up the hook‑wielding terror in modern times.

The film updates the franchise with a blend of old and new, adding complexity that appeals to Gen Z. Its theatrical release sparked timely discussions on whether horror can balance legacy with innovation.

Plot overview

A group of affluent teens accidentally kill someone in a hit‑and‑run and cover it up, only to find themselves haunted by the message “I Know What You Did Last Summer” a year later. The plot progresses from guilt to survival as the Fisherman begins stalking them.

The film alternates between flashbacks to the accident and the escalating terror in Southport. The familiar premise is enhanced with modern twists that engage today’s teen audiences.

Returning characters

Original series survivors Julie James and Ray Bronson return, played by Jennifer Love Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr., respectively. They mentor the new generation while dealing with their own trauma from past events.

Their appearance strengthens the link to the 1997 original and satisfies longtime fans. However, several critics note their screen time is limited and their roles feel more cameo‑like than central.

New cast & Gen Z appeal

The new ensemble includes Madelyn Cline, Chase Sui Wonders, Jonah Hauer‑King, Tyriq Withers, and Sarah Pidgeon, bringing fresh energy. They portray a mix of privilege, rebellion, and emotional complexity that resonates with modern teen viewers.

Chase Sui Wonders, in particular, delivers a grounded performance as Ava that reviewers praised. The younger cast’s chemistry helps carry the film beyond simple nostalgia.

Director’s vision

Jennifer Kaytin Robinson, known for blending tone and nostalgia, takes the helm and co‑writes with Sam Lansky. She infuses the film with satire and humor while respecting slasher conventions.

Critics say she manages to strike a balance between throwback and modern sensibilities. Still, some feel the film wavers between comedic and horrific tones.

Tone & style

The movie oscillates between gore‑filled murder suspense and tongue‑in‑cheek teen drama inspired by reality TV like the “Love Island” vibe. Visuals are slick and bright, with jump scares that shock and self‑referential jokes that ease tension.

Some reviewers say the tonal shifts are uneven, while others appreciate the style. It leans into modern horror clichés while nodding to its roots.

Kill sequences & gore

The Fisherman’s kills are creative, bloody, and delivered with flair, especially in the third act. Iconic hook and harpoon weaponry returns in grisly style for modern audiences.

Critics say the gore hits all the expected slasher beats, though a few feel the earlier kills are stronger. Overall, the visuals are a key highlight for fans of the genre.

Plot twists & revelations

The big twist involves multiple killers, newcomer Stevie and returning Ray, with layered motives tied to survivor guilt and legacy. This break from slasher tropes earned praise for daring narrative choices.

Some say the twist feels earned, while others find it confusing or under‑explained. It definitely redefines expectations and sets up future storylines.

Nostalgia vs freshness

The film walks a tightrope between honoring the 1997 original and offering new content. Fans get callbacks, like returns of the Fisherman, Julie, Ray, and cameo nods to Helen and Karla.

Fresh characters, plot directions, and tech angles (like cryptocurrency jokes) give it a modern edge. Audience reactions suggest a mostly positive reception that did not feel like a simple cash‑grab.

Critical reception

Critics’ opinions are mixed: some laud its nostalgic yet modern take, while others call it shallow or uneven. Rotten Tomatoes highlights strong kills and nostalgia but notes familiar ideas.

Major reviews single out the cast and humor, while others panned its tonal shifts and character writing. On balance, it received decent but not stellar ratings.

Box office performance

With a budget of $18 million, the film grossed $64.4 million worldwide, a modest outcome. Its opening weekend in a slower summer slot reflects both its niche appeal and competition.

Box‑office numbers suggest solid interest but perhaps not mainstream dominance. The performance fits current horror sequel trends where low budgets aim for mid‑tier profits.

Early fan response

Previews in Los Angeles on July 14 got overwhelmingly positive early responses, with audiences praising pace, legacy cameos, and modernization. Many called it one of the best legacy‑sequel revivals after the success of Scream.

The buzz helped drive social media discussions during opening weekend. It’s being mentioned as part of a broader trend in successful horror reboots.

Standout performances

Newcomers like Madelyn Cline and Chase Sui Wonders emerged as scene‑stealers, bringing authenticity. Critics say Jennifer Love Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr. feel misaligned with the tone, causing a slight disconnect.

The ensemble provided clear highlights even when the higher profile actors had limited impact. Strong new talent is generally seen as the film’s biggest asset.

Editing & pacing

At 111 minutes, some critics say the pacing drags with uneven editing rhythm. The second half loses some momentum established in earlier scares, making it feel long.

Early sequences deliver energy but later scenes slow at a critical juncture. Many say tighter editing could have improved flow.

These are the 10 casting rumors that shook Marvel Fans (The Fantastic What-Ifs). Check it out.

Legacy character cameos

Sarah Michelle Gellar and Brandy return as Helen and Karla in dream‑like or end‑credit scenes, hinting at future installments. Their reunions with Hewitt create nostalgic, spine‑tingling moments that energize fans.

These cameos fuel speculation about sequel directions. They are emotional callbacks rather than full story arcs.

Talking about upcoming movies, Tom Holland calls Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey “the job of a lifetime,” says it changed him forever.

If you liked this post, give it a thumbs up and share your thoughts in the comments!

Read More From This Brand:

• Jon Bernthal joins Tom Holland in Spider-Man’s next adventure.
• All the stars set to appear in the new ‘Street Fighter’ reboot.
• “Superman” was called a mess at times, but it still served as a crowd-pleasing cleansing for DC.

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and with human editing.