HBO’s ‘Snape’ Casting Sparks Fan Outrage

Fans Divided Over HBO’s Harry Potter Reboot Casting

Controversy has quickly taken center stage for HBO’s upcoming Harry Potter series. The production platform, HBO, is facing a wave of backlash over its casting decisions.

The initial eagerness for the adaptation has now been turned into something bigger, with debates sparking all over social media platforms. Passionate opinions are taking place, with questions being raised about adaptation, tradition, and inclusivity.

HBO’s Harry Potter Series Announcement

HBO is finally working towards adapting J.K. Rowling’s seven-book Harry Potter series. Each series is going to focus on one book, with an aim to provide a deeper insight into the narrative and characters than the previous film adaptations.

The series will include a completely new cast. Francesca Gardiner, known for her work on Succession and Killing Eve, is serving as the showrunner and writer.

Casting of Albus Dumbledore

Well-known for his roles in 3rd Rock From the Sun and The Crown, John Lithgow has been cast as Professor Dumbledore in the upcoming series.

This casting makes Lithgow the first American to portray the character of Albus Dumbledore. He plans to work with a dialect coach to portray Dumbledore authentically.

The casting decision highlights a departure from the franchise’s tradition of selecting British or Irish actors for major roles. This time around, HBO is intent on bringing fresh perspectives to the table.

Fan Reaction to Dumbledore Casting

The announcement of Lithgow being cast as Dumbledore led to a range of mixed reactions from fans over social media. Several fans expressed great disappointment over the casting of a non-British actor to portray such an iconic British character.

One fan commented on social media, “I think John Lithgow is an amazing actor. However, he is not British, and I feel that the Potter series should keep British actors to maintain the feel.” Others, however, supported the choice, highlighting the actor’s talent and quality of acting.

Introduction of Paapa Essiedu

Paapa Essiedu is known for his dynamic performances across television, film, and theater. He starred as Kwame in the BBC series I May Destroy You (2020), and this role earned him nominations for both Primetime Emmy and British Academy Television Awards.

His television work also includes performances in Gangs of London and The Lazarus Project, and he also appeared in an episode of Black Mirror. He’s a versatile actor and, over time, has become a prominent figure in the British acting industry.

Rumors of Essiedu as Severus Snape

According to surfaced rumors, British actor Paapa Essiedu is in discussions about portraying the famous character Severus Snape in the upcoming television series. Given his portfolio, there’s no doubt why HBO has chosen the actor.

However, the potential casting has sparked debates among fans. Many of them have shared their reservations regarding the choice.

Description of Severus Snape

Severus Snape, in the Harry Potter film series, is shown as a tall, thin man with sallow skin. He has a large hooked nose and uneven, yellow teeth.

His hair is shoulder-length, always greasy, and frames his entire face, complimenting his cold, black eyes. His typical attire consists of black, flowing robes.

Fan Outrage Over Snape Casting

Fans have expressed that choosing Paapa Essiedu means the platform is a significant deviation from the character’s traditional depiction in J.K. Rowling’s novels. Critics argue that Eddiedu’s appearance doesn’t align with Snape’s characteristics.

This has led to apprehension amongst viewers and loyal fans regarding maintaining fidelity to the source material. Fans have also suggested alternative actors for the role.

Fan-Suggested Alternatives for Severus Snape

On top of the list, we’ve got Adam Driver. Adam, well-known for his roles in Star Wars and Marriage Story, is believed to be the perfect fit for Snape.

Others have suggested Benedict Cumberbatch, believing that his experience in playing intelligent and enigmatic characters makes him a natural fit. Richard Armitage from the Hobbit trilogy has also caught the attention of fans.

Accusations of “Blackwashing”

Social media forums are also full of discussions regarding character reinterpretation. Fans are accusing the production of blackwashing.

According to fans online, HBO is pushing the stance of diversity by completely altering a character’s race. One fan commented, “They just don’t learn, do they? People are done with blackwashing…“

Defense of Essiedu’s Casting

There are fans out there who are in full support of Paapa’s casting as Severus Snape. Supporters have highlighted his exceptional talent and the fresh perspective he could bring to the role.

One supporter commented, “I truly do get wanting to broaden the pool of possible choices to all actors possible as a reaction to not having a level playing field for so many generations.” Paapa’s casting as Snape can allow the narrative to be told from a new lens.

Comparison to Alan Rickman’s Snape

Alan Rickman’s portrayal of Severus Snape in the original Harry Potter film series is widely lauded and regarded as iconic. It has set a high standard for the character.

Rickman’s distinctive voice, catching performance, and ability to convey the character’s complexity are truly undisputed. Fans are comparing Paapa Eddiedu to Alan Rickman every step of the way.

Broader Concerns About Casting Choices

The potential casting of Paapa Essiedu has led to discussions about a broader spectrum of debate. Online forums like Reddit include viewers talking about the challenge of prioritizing original character descriptions versus modernizing roles.

Similarly, fans are arguing about the line that production can’t exceed to maintain the fundamental aspects of a story’s authenticity. There’s also widespread debate about modernizing roles for inclusivity.

HBO’s Stance on Diversity

HBO, over the years, has promoted diversity and inclusion in its programming and production processes. In 2018, WarnedMedia, which includes HBO, Warner Bros., and Turner, announced a company-wide commitment to diversity and inclusion.

HBO launched fellowship programs that targeted writers and directors. As a result, underrepresented directors were able to showcase their work.

Potential Effects on Series Success

Controversial casting decisions can have a significant impact on a television series viewership and overall reception. When casting choices go against fans’ expectations, there’s going to be audience backlash.

Talking about Harry Potter, we’ve got 15 magical Harry Potter stars gone too soon who won’t be here when the series is ready for its debut.

Future Casting Speculations

Fans are eager to see more of Harry’s parents, James and Lily Potter, in the upcoming series. Suggestions for James include Aaron Taylor-Johnson and Dev Patel.

Similar to the mystery around casting, there are 15 mysteries in the Harry Potter world that remain unanswered. Who do you think should be cast for James and Lilly Potter? Let us know in the comments, and don’t forget to leave a like.

What do you think about Snape’s casting? Let us know in the comments.

Read More From This Brand:

• Magical Harry Potter Locations You Can Visit
• Harry Potter Easter Eggs to Watch For Next Time
• Harry Potter Stars Honor Maggie Smith’s Memory

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one.