Directors who clashed with stars but still created movie magic

Drama pays

Hollywood history is packed with sets where genius and ego collided like cymbals. But that thunder sometimes sparks electricity, producing classics audiences quote for decades.

Scroll with us as we revisit notorious clashes, shouting matches, fistfights, even guns, between filmmakers and their stars. Because when tempers flare and cameras keep rolling, movie magic can still emerge in the final cut, against all odds.

Kubrick vs. Duvall

On the set of The Shining, director Stanley Kubrick’s relentless pursuit of perfection led to Shelley Duvall performing the infamous baseball bat scene 127 times.

The emotional toll was so severe that Duvall experienced physical illness and hair loss, presenting clumps of her hair to Kubrick as evidence of her distress.

Despite the grueling experience, Duvall’s performance contributed to the film’s enduring legacy as a horror classic. Her portrayal of Wendy Torrance remains a testament to her resilience and dedication to her craft.

Russell vs. Clooney

During the production of Three Kings, tensions escalated between director David O. Russell and actor George Clooney due to Russell’s treatment of the crew. The situation culminated in a physical altercation after Clooney intervened when Russell allegedly mistreated an extra.

Despite the on-set conflict, the film was completed and received critical acclaim for its unique storytelling and performances. However, Clooney has since expressed his unwillingness to work with Russell again, citing the negative experience.

Cameron vs. Harris

Filming The Abyss was an arduous experience for actor Ed Harris, who endured long hours underwater under director James Cameron’s demanding direction.

The intense conditions led to Harris experiencing a near-drowning incident, after which he reportedly refused to discuss the film publicly.

Despite the challenges, The Abyss was lauded for its groundbreaking visual effects and storytelling. The film’s success stands as a testament to the cast and crew’s dedication amidst trying circumstances.

Herzog vs. Kinski

Director Werner Herzog and actor Klaus Kinski’s tumultuous collaboration on Fitzcarraldo was marked by intense arguments and threats. The tension was so palpable that local tribesmen reportedly offered to kill Kinski to ease the production’s strain.

Herzog declined the offer, and the film was completed, showcasing the duo’s volatile yet creatively fruitful partnership. Fitzcarraldo remains a remarkable achievement in cinema, reflecting the passion and chaos behind its creation.

Fincher vs. Weaver

David Fincher’s directorial debut with Alien 3 was fraught with challenges, including constant studio interference that limited his creative control. Sigourney Weaver, reprising her role as Ripley, expressed frustration over the chaotic production.

Fincher was not allowed to work with his own script, which hindered the film’s development.

Despite these obstacles, Alien 3 was completed and has since gained a cult following, with some appreciating its darker tone and thematic depth. Weaver acknowledged that, despite the difficulties, she enjoyed working with Fincher and felt they made a good film under the circumstances.

Coppola vs. Brando

During the production of Apocalypse Now, director Francis Ford Coppola faced significant challenges with actor Marlon Brando, who arrived on set overweight and unprepared.

Brando’s insistence on improvisation and refusal to learn his lines forced Coppola to adapt, leading to a filming approach that involved shooting Brando in shadows to conceal his appearance.

Despite these hurdles, Brando’s portrayal of Colonel Kurtz became iconic, contributing to the film’s critical acclaim. Coppola later reflected on the experience, acknowledging Brando’s genius and the extraordinary contribution he made to the film.

Scott vs. Ford

On the set of Blade Runner, director Ridley Scott and actor Harrison Ford experienced creative tensions, particularly regarding the interpretation of Ford’s character, Deckard.

Scott’s vision of Deckard as a replicant clashed with Ford’s desire for the character to be human, leading to disagreements during production.

Additionally, Scott’s directing style, which involved isolating himself in a video playback booth, created a disconnect with the actors. Despite these challenges, Blade Runner emerged as a seminal work in science fiction cinema.

Spielberg vs. Shaw

During the filming of Jaws, tensions arose between director Steven Spielberg and actor Robert Shaw, who portrayed the character Quint. Shaw’s heavy drinking and antagonistic behavior towards co-star Richard Dreyfuss created a challenging atmosphere on set.

Despite these difficulties, Shaw’s performance added depth to the film, and the on-screen tension between Quint and Dreyfuss’s character, Hooper, contributed to the movie’s dynamic. Spielberg later acknowledged that the real-life friction between the actors enhanced their performances.

Tarantino vs. Thurman

On the set of Kill Bill, director Quentin Tarantino and actress Uma Thurman experienced a significant conflict when Thurman was involved in a car crash during filming.

Thurman had expressed concerns about performing a driving stunt, but was persuaded by Tarantino to proceed, resulting in an accident that caused her lasting injuries.

The incident strained their professional relationship, with Thurman later describing the experience as dehumanizing. Tarantino has since expressed deep regret over the event, calling it one of the biggest regrets of his life.

Polanski vs. Dunaway

During Chinatown, Roman Polanski insisted Faye Dunaway stay in a waiting car during a long sit‑in scene. Dunaway responded by hurling a drink at Polanski in full costume, shouting expletives, igniting what’s often dubbed the “toilet‑break feud.”

Despite tensions, Dunaway’s on‑screen mystery glows in the final cut, her discomfort giving Grace Kelly–style allure and cementing Chinatown as a noir masterpiece.

Kaye vs. Norton

For American History X, director Tony Kaye and Edward Norton fought fiercely over final cut rights. Kaye’s erratic behavior drove the studio to let Norton re‑edit the film, dominating the film’s tone and pacing.

In the end, Norton’s version premiered to critical praise and an Oscar nomination, while Kaye’s original cut remains unreleased, a creative clash that fundamentally shaped the film’s legacy.

Clint Eastwood vs. Philip Kaufman

On The Outlaw Josey Wales, Clint Eastwood fired original director Philip Kaufman mid‑production and assumed directing duties. The Directors Guild fined Eastwood’s team $60,000 and passed the “Eastwood Rule,” preventing actors from firing directors to take the helm themselves.

Eastwood’s takeover didn’t derail the film; it’s considered a visceral Western classic. But the precedent‑setting backlash reshaped Guild protections forever.

Tarantino vs. DiCaprio

On Django Unchained, Quentin Tarantino and Leonardo DiCaprio sparred creatively about Calvin Candie’s character depth, and DiCaprio admitted discomfort with the character’s brutal racism.

Tarantino encouraged him to push through that unease to serve the storytelling, leading to an intensely layered performance.

That moral tension sharpened DiCaprio’s chilling portrayal, earning him critical praise. The film went on to gross over $425 million and became Tarantino’s biggest hit at the time.

Gilliam vs. Depp

During Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, Terry Gilliam’s chaotic shoot style and Johnny Depp’s improvisational energy clashed frequently, leading to heated tempers on set. Depp reportedly thrived on that tension, which mirrored his character’s unpredictable journey.

Though production was tumultuous, the friction lent authenticity to the drug-fueled narrative, and the film has since achieved cult classic status. Gilliam and Depp’s push-pull fueled that surreal energy onscreen.

Depp’s chaotic brilliance hasn’t dimmed. See why fans are buzzing about his next bold move in The Carnival at the End of Days.

Fincher vs. Pitt

While The Curious Case of Benjamin Button didn’t erupt in public fights, David Fincher and Brad Pitt engaged in intense editing-room debates about pacing and emotional tone. Pitt wanted more warmth, while Fincher pushed for somber restraint, sparking impassioned creative back-and-forth.

That dynamic led to a richer final cut balancing melancholy with tenderness, earning the film three Oscar wins and two nominations. Their respectful clash illustrated how tension can refine a story’s heart.

For more directors whose bold choices made history, check out Hollywood’s greatest directors and their hits.

Ever heard of a fiery director-actor duo that still delivered gold? Drop your favorite behind-the-scenes clash that led to movie magic in the comments.

Read More From This Brand:

• Brad Pitt & Fincher Reunite for Netflix Sequel
• Cinema’s Game-Changing Women Directors
• Nominees for 2025 Directors Guild Awards

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first one to get stories like this one.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.