6 min read
Was Disney’s Snow White doomed from the start, or did its lead actress, Rachel Zegler, play a role in its box office failure?
The long-awaited live-action remake has been surrounded by controversy for years, but now, Jonah Platt—the son of producer Marc Platt—has publicly blamed Zegler for the film’s poor performance.
In a since-deleted Instagram comment, he accused the actress of letting her personal politics overshadow the movie, claiming it hurt ticket sales.
So, did Zegler’s outspoken social media posts really impact Snow White’s success, or was it just another misstep in Disney’s struggling live-action remake strategy? Keep reading as we break down the drama!
The trouble started on August 12, 2024, when Zegler took the stage at Disney’s D23 fan event to introduce the first official trailer.
After celebrating the teaser’s viral success of 120 million views in 24 hours, she posted on social media: “And always remember, free Palestine.” That statement, which amassed nearly 9 million views, quickly overshadowed the film itself.
Within Disney, executives were alarmed. A Disney producer contacted Zegler’s team, and Marc Platt personally flew to New York to confront her. The studio urged her to delete the post, fearing it would alienate audiences, but Zegler stood firm.

This wasn’t the first time Zegler’s outspoken nature had ruffled feathers. Her comments about the original 1937 Snow White—where she called the Prince a “stalker” and dismissed the classic love story—had already put her at odds with traditional Disney fans.
But the “Free Palestine” post took things to another level. It not only intensified backlash from some corners of the audience but also led to security concerns for her Snow White co-star, Gal Gadot, an Israeli actress. Disney was forced to increase Gadot’s security after an uptick in death threats.
Months later, as Snow White’s release approached, Zegler made headlines again.
Following the 2024 U.S. presidential election, she posted, “F*** Donald Trump” and “May Trump supporters … never know peace.” This further fueled controversy, with Disney executives growing increasingly concerned that the actress was alienating a significant portion of the film’s potential audience.
Jonah Platt weighed in on the situation via Instagram, defending his father’s decision to confront Zegler and criticizing her for prioritizing personal politics over professionalism.
“This is called adult responsibility and accountability,” Platt wrote in the since deleted comment.
“Tens of thousands of people worked on that film, and she hijacked the conversation for her own immature desires at the risk of all the colleagues and crew and blue-collar workers who depend on that movie to be successful. Narcissism is not something to be coddled or encouraged.”
His comments sparked debate, with some agreeing that Zegler’s approach to activism had negatively impacted the film’s marketing, while others defended her right to free speech. Regardless, Disney had had enough.
The company reportedly hired a social media specialist to monitor Zegler’s posts in an attempt to control the damage before the film’s March 21 release.
Despite Disney’s efforts, Snow White struggled at the box office.
Opening at just $43 million domestically, it was a stunning failure for a film that should have been a financial juggernaut. Compared to Warner Bros.’s Joker: Folie à Deux, which earned $121 million on its opening weekend despite costing $70 million less to make, Snow White looked like a disaster.
“You can’t say that a live-action remake of the most iconic film in the vault that cost $270 million and has been reshot multiple times opening to $50 million is OK,” Variety reported an anonymous studio executive’s comment. “The math does not work. That movie should be a billion-dollar movie.”
Disney had already been struggling with live-action remakes. Films like Dumbo, Peter Pan & Wendy, and Maleficent: Mistress of Evil had all underperformed.
But Snow White was supposed to be different. Instead, it became a cautionary tale about how a film’s marketing—and the personal choices of its lead actor—can influence its success.
In the aftermath of the box office disaster, industry insiders are questioning Disney’s handling of Zegler.
Some argue that the studio should have distanced itself from her sooner, especially after her controversial Oscars campaign for West Side Story in 2022, where she publicly complained about not being invited despite starring in a Best Picture nominee.

Others believe Disney mishandled the Snow White controversy from the start, failing to take control of the narrative early enough.
Meanwhile, Zegler has remained silent on the film’s poor performance, and Disney has declined to comment on whether her public statements played a role in its failure.
One thing is clear: Hollywood is still figuring out how to navigate the complex relationship between social media activism and blockbuster filmmaking.
While controversy can sometimes fuel interest in a film, in this case, it appears to have done more harm than good.
Did Rachel Zegler’s political activism tank Snow White’s box office? The answer isn’t black and white.
A combination of factors—including reshoots, production delays, and a changing audience appetite for live-action remakes—certainly played a role. However, Jonah Platt’s claim that Zegler’s public statements hurt the film’s success can’t be dismissed entirely.
As Hollywood continues to grapple with the power of social media and the influence of politically outspoken stars, the Snow White debacle serves as a warning. For Disney, the question now is: How will they prevent this from happening again?
We appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback about this page with us.
Whether it's praise for something good, or ideas to improve something that
isn't quite right, we're excited to hear from you.
Lucky you! This thread is empty,
which means you've got dibs on the first comment.
Go for it!