Country albums’ unexpected polarizing songs

Country albums’ flop songs

Country music is all about strong stories, big feelings, and albums that people still love today. But even the best albums sometimes have songs that fans and critics don’t all like.

Some songs caused trouble because of their words, strange sounds, or just not being good enough. Even when an album is loved, certain songs still start a lot of arguments.

These songs show that even famous country stars can get things wrong sometimes. Let’s look at some surprising mistakes in albums!

Accidental Racist – Brad Paisley feat. LL Cool J (2013)

Brad Paisley’s 2013 album Wheelhouse is one of his biggest and boldest albums. But even great albums can have bad songs, and “Accidental Racist” is one of them.

This song, with rapper LL Cool J, tried to talk about racism but upset a lot of people. Critics said it was wrong to compare things like gold chains and do-rags to the Confederate flag, which stands for slavery.

Lines like “If you don’t judge my gold chains, I’ll forget the iron chains” were called insensitive. Some people said the song made slavery seem less serious.

Indian Outlaw – Tim McGraw (1994)

Tim McGraw’s 1994 song “Indian Outlaw,” from his album Not a Moment Too Soon, got a lot of backlash. Native American groups said some of the lyrics were offensive.

Two country radio stations in Minneapolis even refused to play the song because of these complaints. The song talks about a wild, outlaw character, but many people thought the way it described Native Americans was disrespectful.

The Pill – Loretta Lynn (1975)

Loretta Lynn’s 1975 song “The Pill,” from her album Back to the Country, got a lot of attention for talking about birth control, which was a very bold topic for country music back then.

Many country radio stations thought it was too risky and refused to play it. Because of that, the song’s chart performance was delayed and it couldn’t become a top three hit.

Still, it got lots of publicity and became her highest-charting pop single, reaching number 70 on the Hot 100.

Red Ragtop – Tim McGraw (2002)

Tim McGraw’s 2002 song “Red Ragtop,” from his album Tim McGraw and the Dancehall Doctors, caused a lot of controversy. Some people thought the song talked about abortion, even though it didn’t say it directly.

Because of this, some radio stations, like WSM-FM in Nashville, pulled the song after only a few plays. Online comments also said the lyrics seemed racist, anti-BLM, and pro-gun.

Goodbye Earl – The Chicks (2000)

The Dixie Chicks’ (now The Chicks) 2000 song “Goodbye Earl,” from their album Fly, caused a lot of controversy. The song tells the story of two women who kill Wanda’s abusive husband, Earl, funnily and darkly.

Some people thought it was wrong to joke about something as serious as domestic violence. Some radio stations refused to play the song, while others played it but shared domestic violence hotline numbers.

Try That in a Small Town – Jason Aldean (2023)

Jason Aldean’s 2023 song “Try That in a Small Town,” from his album Highway Desperado, caused a lot of controversy. People said the song and video were racist, glorified violence, and supported vigilante justice.

Critics pointed out the video was filmed at a courthouse where a lynching happened and used footage that seemed against the Black Lives Matter movement.

Aldean said the song is not about race but about community, safety, and wanting a normal life back. Some channels, like CMT, even removed the video.

Corn Star – Craig Morgan (2012)

Craig Morgan’s 2012 song “Corn Star,” from his album This Ole Boy, got both good and bad feedback. Some critics said the lyrics, while G-rated, felt a little sleazy and better suited for a younger singer. Reviews said the song was sweet but didn’t feel fresh for Morgan’s career.

Some also thought it made women seem like objects. Even with the criticism, many fans loved the fun beat and strong mix of rock guitars and banjo. “Corn Star” became a fan favorite at concerts, and it even inspired T-shirts.

Truck Yeah – Tim McGraw (2012)

Tim McGraw’s 2012 song “Truck Yeah,” from his album Two Lanes of Freedom, got a lot of mixed reactions. Critics said the song was too simple, predictable, and made just to get radio play.

They thought it used basic country stereotypes and didn’t offer anything fresh or original. Some even said it sounded “goofily catchy” and “dumb.” People also complained that the singing was boring and didn’t change much.

Boys ‘Round Here – Blake Shelton (2013)

Blake Shelton’s 2013 song “Boys ‘Round Here,” from his hit album Based on a True Story…, got a lot of criticism even though the album was very successful.

Some reviewers said the song sounded immature and was just a bunch of popular words put together with no real meaning. They thought the lyrics about drinking beer, smoking, and hanging out by the river were old and boring.

Save a Horse (Ride a Cowboy) – Big & Rich (2004)

Big & Rich’s 2004 song “Save a Horse (Ride a Cowboy),” from their album Horse of a Different Color, got a lot of attention, both good and bad. Some critics said the song’s lyrics were too silly and didn’t show the real cowboy life.

Others thought the way it was used in the movie Magic Mike made fun of country music. Many called it a “novelty hit” because it was more funny than serious. Still, fans loved its humor and fun style.

Body Like a Back Road – Sam Hunt (2017)

Sam Hunt’s 2017 song “Body Like a Back Road,” from his album Southside, got a lot of criticism even though it was a big hit. Some critics said it didn’t sound like real country music because it mixed in too much pop and R&B.

People also said it fit too much into the “bro-country” trend, focusing on looks and partying. Some felt it didn’t show enough respect for women. Even with the complaints, the song became super popular and helped make Southside a huge success.

She Thinks My Tractor’s Sexy – Kenny Chesney (1999)

Kenny Chesney’s 1999 song “She Thinks My Tractor’s Sexy,” from his album Everywhere We Go, was a big hit but got some criticism too. Critics said the song’s lyrics were too simple and cliché, just about a woman liking a man’s tractor.

Some felt it didn’t show the deep feelings that good country music usually has. Even Kenny admitted the song was “silly” and didn’t have much “gray area.” While the song made a lot of people smile, it sometimes made fans forget about Kenny’s deeper songs.

Dirt Road Anthem – Jason Aldean (2010)

Jason Aldean’s 2010 song “Dirt Road Anthem” from his album My Kinda Party got mixed reviews. Some critics, like Matt Bjorke of Roughstock, liked how Aldean added a rap verse, calling it fresh and different from normal country music.

But others, like Kevin John Coyne of Country Universe, said the lyrics used old ideas and felt boring. Some didn’t like Aldean mixing rap with country at all, even calling him “the country music Grimmace.”

You’ve Never Been This Far Before – Conway Twitty (1973)

Conway Twitty’s 1973 song “You’ve Never Been This Far Before” from his album You’ve Never Been This Far Before caused controversy because some people thought the lyrics were too sexual.

The song talks about a man and his less experienced girlfriend, which made some radio stations ban it. At the time, America was becoming more open, but some still thought the song was inappropriate.

Even with the bans, the song became a huge hit. It was Twitty’s only country song to cross into the Billboard Hot 100’s Top 40, reaching number 22, making it one of his biggest successes.

Would You Lay With Me (In a Field of Stone) – Tanya Tucker (1973)

Tanya Tucker’s 1973 song “Would You Lay With Me (In a Field of Stone)” from her album Would You Lay With Me (In a Field of Stone) got some mixed reactions. Some people thought the lyrics were too suggestive, especially the line “Would you lay with me in a field of stone.”

At least one radio station banned the song because of it. Others misunderstood the meaning, even though writer David Allan Coe said it was about eternal love.

Check out these 15 controversial country album covers that were released and faced backlash.

Girl Crush – Little Big Town (2014)

Little Big Town’s song “Girl Crush” is from their album Pain Killer and it caused a lot of talk when it came out. Some listeners thought lines like wanting to “taste her lips” meant the song was about a lesbian crush and even claimed it was pushing a “gay agenda.”

Others felt the lyrics were too grown-up and not right for younger audiences. A lot of people misunderstood the song, which was actually about being jealous of another woman.

If you’re a fan, check out Little Big Town’s star-studded summer tour ‘25.

Have you listened to any of these songs? Hit like and share your thoughts in the comments!

Read More From This Brand:

• Debut to Iconic Albums That Changed Music
• Most Anticipated Upcoming Country Albums of 2025
• New Waterboys Album Honors Dennis Hopper

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.