American Idol Top 7 Cut To Final Five

Platinum Tickets, No More

On May 4, “American Idol” shockingly eliminated its remaining platinum ticket holders, shaking up the competition. These contestants, once considered frontrunners, were ousted just before the Top 7 reveal. Their early advantage didn’t guarantee safety, proving that public votes now dominate the narrative.

The surprise left fans buzzing about who truly has what it takes to win. The cuts marked a pivotal shift as the show moved into its most intense phase yet. With no immunity left and every performance under scrutiny, the tension reached new heights. The golden edge is gone; now, talent must stand alone.

Top 8 Vote Shocker

The May 5 episode saw the competition narrow to the Top 7 after a brutal round of fan voting. Canaan James Hill and Kolbi Jordan were eliminated in a surprising twist. The audience’s votes proved unpredictable, eliminating two strong contenders.

Judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie were then tasked with making one final, painful decision after a whispered conference. Ultimately, Mattie Pruitt was sent home, despite an emotional plea in her performance. Her tearful goodbye left fans stunned.

Season 23’s unpredictability continues, and with each cut, the stakes rise for those who remain in the spotlight.

Judges Spar Over Save

The anonymous “Judge’s Song Contest” tested more than just the contestants; it sparked unexpected drama among the panel. Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie both won bragging rights after three singers chose their songs. That victory came with added responsibility: saving one of the bottom three.

Meanwhile, Carrie Underwood didn’t take kindly to being left out of the decision-making process. “I don’t lose,” she snapped, only to later welcome the reprieve. The pressure of choosing who stays or goes weighs on the judges. The episode proved that tension doesn’t only exist onstage, it’s behind the desk too.

Carrie’s Competitive Streak Surfaces

Carrie Underwood’s sharp declaration, “I don’t lose on American Idol,” offered a rare glimpse of her fierce competitive streak. Despite her irritation, she ultimately stepped back from the final elimination decision, allowing Bryan and Richie to confer.

The moment was a reminder that even judges feel the emotional toll of the competition. Carrie’s candid reaction added drama to the already tense night, but her later support for the remaining contestants showed grace under pressure.

As a former winner herself, her investment in this year’s talent is personal. Still, even idols sometimes prefer not to choose who falls.

Mattie’s Journey Ends Tearfully

Mattie Pruitt, the talented airport pianist, saw her journey end as Bryan and Richie chose not to save her. On the brink of tears, Mattie stood frozen as her name was called. The judges’ decision left fans emotional, especially after her heartfelt performances.

Despite her exit, Mattie had a notable arc, growing in confidence and poise throughout the season. Her pure tone and sincere delivery won hearts, and her departure proves that no one is truly safe. Her goodbye was heartbreaking, especially as she had been gaining momentum. Still, her growth was undeniable and unforgettable.

Meet The Top Seven

Season 23’s Top 7 include John Foster, Jamal Roberts, Mattie Pruitt, Thunderstorm Artis, Slater Nalley, Gabby Samone, and Breanna Nix. With diverse styles, backgrounds, and strengths, the competition’s diversity shines more than ever. From gospel roots to singer-songwriter soul, each artist brings something distinct to the table.

Their recent performances at Disneyland, under the guidance of Lin-Manuel Miranda, highlighted both vulnerability and versatility. These seven singers must now prove their worth week after week. As the fanbase tightens and competition intensifies, every note, lyric, and moment matters. Only five can move forward, and nobody’s guaranteed a spot.

Magic Mentoring From Miranda

Lin-Manuel Miranda served as a mentor during the special Disney-themed episode, guiding each contestant through their chosen songs. The creative genius behind Moana and Hamilton helped elevate the performances with sharp insight and heartfelt encouragement.

His presence added prestige and motivation, inspiring singers to tap deeper into their emotions. With his help, the Top 7 explored Disney’s timeless stories while connecting them to personal truths. His mentorship reminded viewers that music isn’t just about technical skill, it’s storytelling.

Miranda’s influence was felt throughout the night as performers pushed past comfort zones and delivered career-defining moments onstage.

Gabby’s Crescendo Shines Bright

Gabby Samone delivered a standout performance with “How Far I’ll Go” from Moana. Her voice soared, capturing the spirit of the song’s yearning. Lionel Richie praised her for bringing a show-stopping moment, calling the crescendo “a light” shining on her.

Carrie Underwood agreed, declaring Gabby’s voice perfect for emotionally powerful songs. This Disney performance became one of Gabby’s strongest yet. Despite her later elimination, Gabby left a lasting impression with her clarity, control, and heartfelt delivery.

It was a night where she truly claimed the spotlight, and proved that talent can still leave a mark, win or lose.

Jamal’s Emotional Vocal Journey

Jamal Roberts sang “Go the Distance” from Hercules and later paid tribute to his stepmother with “A Change Is Gonna Come.” Both performances struck a deep emotional chord. Carrie Underwood applauded his ability to personalize every song, calling it his artistic signature.

His delivery showed range and emotional resonance, especially on the soulful Sam Cooke classic. His journey on Idol has showcased his adaptability and storytelling skills. Even as themes change, Jamal continues to make each song his own. These performances cemented his spot in the Top 5, proving he’s more than just technically strong, he’s deeply moving.

Breanna’s Poise and Power

Breanna Nix was stunned by “Reflection” from Mulan, followed by a tearful “Like My Mother Does” performance. With both songs, she showcased emotional depth, vocal precision, and elegant restraint. Luke Bryan admired her total control, while Richie praised her grace and ability to emote through melody.

During her Mother’s Day tribute, Breanna got choked up but pulled through with heart and composure. Carrie Underwood, moved to tears, called it beautiful. Breanna’s performances were a masterclass in vulnerability and strength, earning her a well-deserved place in the Top 5.

She proved that quiet power can command the loudest applause.

Foster Channels Louisiana Roots

John Foster honored his Louisiana roots with “Almost There” from The Princess and the Frog. His stage presence electrified the audience, earning wild applause and rave reviews. Carrie Underwood commended him for staying true to himself regardless of genre.

Later, his Mother’s Day performance of “Believe” by Brooks & Dunn brought heartfelt simplicity to the stage. John’s charm, confidence, and authenticity make him a consistent crowd-pleaser. He’s versatile yet unmistakably unique, a blend that’s rare in the competition.

With each performance, John continues to build a strong case as a finalist contender. His journey is gaining unstoppable momentum.

Slater Stumbles, Then Soars

Slater Nalley faced a near-disaster when he forgot the lyrics at the start of “Can You Feel the Love Tonight?” But with admirable composure, he recovered quickly and finished strong. Luke Bryan reassured him that even professionals blank under pressure, praising his rebound.

Later, Slater honored his mom with Bob Dylan’s “Don’t Think Twice, It’s Alright.” The heartfelt performance impressed Carrie Underwood, who admired his ease and emotional honesty. Slater’s resilience and growth have defined his arc.

While not always flawless, he shows heart, and in Idol, that’s sometimes what counts most. One stumble didn’t stop his rise.

Thunderstorm’s Emotional Masterclass

Thunderstorm Artis delivered two of the night’s most powerful performances, “Colors of the Wind” and an original tribute to his wife. His voice, often described as haunting and soulful, captivated the room. Lionel Richie called him an “amazing storyteller,” while Carrie Underwood nearly cried, overwhelmed by his arrangement.

Thunderstorm’s original song revealed depth as both a writer and performer, prompting Richie to predict a lasting career. Consistently emotionally resonant and musically refined, Thunderstorm is carving a unique lane. His artistry is undeniable, his delivery magnetic.

Gabby’s Farewell Leaves Impact

Gabby Samone didn’t make it to the Top 5, but her final performances were among her most memorable. “How Far I’ll Go” and “Home” displayed her emotional range and vocal maturity. She honored her mother with grace, telling a story of strength and sacrifice.

Judges stood to applaud her, especially Luke Bryan, who called it his favorite performance of the year. Despite elimination, Gabby exits with dignity and momentum. Fans won’t forget her commanding voice and tender delivery.

Mattie’s Growth Cut Short

Mattie Pruitt was eliminated after her most expressive performances to date, “Remember Me” and “Raised By Those Kind of Women.” Judges commended her maturity, sass, and confidence. Luke Bryan highlighted her development from a shy high-schooler to a poised performer.

Carrie Underwood called her song choice intentional and heartfelt. Yet, fan votes didn’t fall in her favor. Her exit was bittersweet, coming just as she found her footing. Mattie may no longer compete, but her evolution left a lasting impression.

She’s proof that Idol is about growth, not just winning. Her future in music feels promising. And speaking of growth, Luke & Carrie’s secret was finally revealed on ‘American Idol’, adding another layer of surprise to an already emotional episode.

Final Five Take Spotlight

As Season 23 nears its climax, the Top 5 are: Thunderstorm Artis, John Foster, Slater Nalley, Jamal Roberts, and Breanna Nix. This group represents the season’s best blend of emotional depth, technical prowess, and unique artistry. Each has carved a distinct lane, making the next elimination even more unpredictable.

Disney Night Part Two looms ahead, promising more magic, and more heartbreak. With Gabby and Mattie gone, the remaining contestants must dig deeper to stay alive. One thing’s clear: the crown is truly up for grabs. And with these five, any finale would be worthy of a standing ovation.

Oh, and did you catch Jelly Roll’s new role on ‘American Idol’? He’s just as excited about it as the fans are. What do you think of this season’s Top 5? Let us know, your voice matters just as much as your vote.

Read More From This Brand:

• American Idol’s Easter Special with Jelly Roll & More
• American Idol’s Top 8 Revealed — Shocking Exit Stuns Fans
• Country Music’s Biggest Feuds and Rivalries

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one.