All You Need to Know About Only Murders in the Building Season 5

What to Expect in Only Murders in the Building Season 5

Only Murders in the Building has kept fans hooked for four thrilling seasons. The perfect mix of comedy, suspense, and unexpected twists is what keeps the fans on the edge of their seats.

Season 5 is expected to deliver the same and so much more. The stakes are higher than ever, given the shocking events of the season 4 finale.

Recap of Season 4 Finale

The season 4 finale of Only Murders in the Building brought closure to exciting mysteries. But, it not only ended events but also made way for new ones.

The trio – Charles, Oliver, and Mabel uncovered that Marshall P. Pope, also known as Rex Bailer, was responsible for Sazz Pataki’s murder. The moment this mystery ended, it was discovered that Lester, the building’s doorman, was dead.

Season 5 Renewal Announcement

Hulu has officially renewed Only Murders in the Building for a fifth season. The announcement was made at the initial stages of the premiere of the fourth season.

This eagerness showcases the streaming platform’s confidence in the series. Fans can expect the same blend of humor, intrigue, and star-studded guest appearances in the upcoming season.

Main Cast Returning

The core trio is, of course, going to reprise their roles in the upcoming fifth season. Their dynamic history has been the largest contributor to the show’s success.

The trio’s return sets the stage for another season that’s based on engaging storytelling. Nobody solves a murder mystery better than Steve Martin (Charles), Martin Short (Oliver), and Selena Gomez (Mabel Mora).

Supporting Cast Members

Several supporting cast actors are also set to make their return for Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building. Michael Cyril Creighton will continue with his role as Howard Morris.

Jackie Hoffman will be making a return as Uma Heller, known for her sharp wit and calm personality. Da’Vine Joy Randolph is going to reprise her role as Detective Donna Williams.

New Cast Additions

Season 5 features exciting new cast members, including Renée Zellweger, Bobby Cannavale, Christoph Waltz, Beanie Feldstein, Logan Lerman, Jermaine Fowler, and Keegan-Michael Key.

Zellweger was spotted filming in Brooklyn with a dramatic new look. These high-profile additions promise to bring fresh energy, intrigue, and humor, expanding the mystery’s scope and elevating anticipation for the show’s return.

Filming Locations

Season 5 began filming in March 2025 across New York City, including Staten Island and the Upper West Side, with the Belnord again portraying the Arconia. Key scenes are being shot near the iconic “Godfather” house.

Production is on track to wrap by June 2025, aligning with Hulu’s traditional summer release pattern for the series.

Premiere Window

Although Hulu hasn’t confirmed an exact premiere date, Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building is expected to debut in August 2025. This aligns with previous release patterns.

If post-production extends, a fall premiere around October is also possible. Fans can expect the return to coincide with late-summer or early-fall streaming schedules.

Plot Teasers

Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building will be heavily focused on the death of Lester, Arconia’s long-serving doorman. The narrative will shed light on Lester’s personal connections and hidden facets of his life.

According to John Hoffman, the investigation around the murder will get “very complex.” This suggests that the upcoming season will lead to deeper secrets tied to Lester’s death and Arconia’s residents.

Themes Explored

Season 5 is going to be heavy on the rich tapestry of New York City’s history. The city’s dynamic character and its intricacies will be at the forefront of the series.

Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building is going to utilize the Belnord as the stand-in for the Arconia. Both historical and modern elements of the city will be integrated into the storyline and settings.

Guest Stars

Besides the addition of Téa Leoni, other notable guest stars are set to join the ensemble cast, creating buzz among the fans. Keegan-Michael Key has also been cast in a recurring role for the upcoming season.

However, the specific details about his character are still under wraps. The show’s tradition of introducing high-profile guests is expected to continue.

Behind-the-Scenes Insights

Co-creator and showrunner John Hoffman shared details about the creative process behind the series’ authentic portrayal of the narrative. He shared, “In the year before [we filmed], I had my own experience like none other in my life…”

He continued to add, “I found myself driven to understand what was going on. All of these emotional feelings came up as I was exploring those questions about how it happened.”

Awards and Recognition

Only Murders in the Building received widespread recognition at the 2025 Screen Actors Guild (SAG) Awards. It won the award for Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Comedy Series.

Selena Gomez, who portrays the character of Mabel Mora, accepted the award on behalf of the ensemble. Selena Gomez, while receiving the award, stated, “Marty and Steve aren’t here because… you know, they don’t really care,” humorously hinting at the co-stars’ absence.

Fan Theories

As anticipation builds for season 5 of Only Murders in the Building, fans have started developing their theories about the upcoming series. The unexpected death of Lester, according to fans, will lead to a web of secrets tied to Arconia’s history.

There are unresolved mysteries from season 1, including anonymous threats and the poisoning of Oliver’s dog. This has led to fans proposing the existence of an antagonist working from the shadows.

Streaming Platforms

As with previous seasons, season 5 will premiere exclusively on Hulu. Viewers outside the U.S. can stream season 5 on Disney+.

Paradise renewed for season 2 on Hulu, which has also created quite a lot of noise over social media platforms. Just like Only Murders in the Building, this series has an intriguing narrative and a loyal fan base.

Critical Expectations

Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building is expected to continue the same trend of high-quality storytelling. In 2024, the series received 21 Emmy Nominations.

Given the track record, season 5 is going to keep up with the high expectations. The White Lotus is also getting a fourth season.

You must be thinking, why did the White Lotus earn a season 4 renewal? Well, the answer lies in its intriguing plot.

Read More From This Brand

• Reba McEntire’s ‘Happy Place’ Renewed for Season 2
• The Lincoln Lawyer Gets Renewed for Season 4
• “Emily in Paris” Renewed for Season 5, Confirms Lily Collins

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

If you liked this story, you’ll LOVE our FREE emails. Join today and be the first to get stories like this one.